Not doing every Creepypasta character, just doing the main ones plus some of my favorites!

Sexualities and genders!
Slenderman: Asexual, aromatic and either male or agender
Jeff the killer: Straight, demiromatic and male
Eyeless Jack: Idk but either male or non binary
Ben drowned: Either straight or bisexual, maybe demisexual and male
Ticci Toby: Pansexual, maybe demisexual and either male or gender fluid
Masky: Gay, demiromatic and male
Hoodie: Gay, demisexual and either male or non binary
Laughing Jack: Either pansexual or gay, demisexual and either male or non binary
Jane the killer: Straight, demisexual and female
Nina the killer: Straight and female
Sally: Pansexual, asexual and female
Liu: Either straight or bisexual, demisexual, demiromatic and male
Clockwork: Either straight or bisexual, either asexual or demisexual and female
Lazari: Lesbian, asexual and female
Pinkamena: Pansexual, either asexual or demisexual and female
Rainbow factory: Lesbian, demisexual, demiromatic and female
Sonic.exe: Straight and male
Sally.exe: Either straight or pansexual and female
Herobrine: Either gay or bisexual, demiromatic and either male or non binary
Lost silver: Pansexual, asexual and either male or non binary
Zalgo: Omnisexual, aromatic and either male or agender

My ships!
Jeff the killer x Jane the killer
Ticci Toby x Masky
Masky x Hoodie
Ticci Toby x Clockwork
Sally x Lazari
Rainbow factory x Pinkamena
Sonic.exe x Sally.exe