Just a warning because this one will be very long and kinda of angsty, but there will also be smut hehe

Tim was laying in bed. He normally would have been up, but he just...couldn't find a reason to be up. It was around the time Jay had gone missing, just a day before his 'proxy anniversary' bullshit. He remembered the pain of seeing Jay's dead body, finding out who Brian really was...it tore him up. Since he couldn't live a normal life, he let Slenderman take him in anyways.

Not long after, Slender started bringing new proxies in. First it was Brian, which was a very interesting reunion. They hugged like they would die if they didn't.

Then there was Kate. She was very quiet, even more so then Brian, but she was sweet.
Then...oh boy, then there was Toby. Slender protected that boy like he was his own child. Toby smelt of fire and had ash and blood all over him when he first arrived. Slender made them promise to keep him happy....which they did.

But god was Toby fucking annoying. He would go on and on and on and on, he would harass Masky just for fun. Tim prayed to god that no other proxies would show up after Toby. To add to it, Kate became much more comfortable and would be just as annoying.

So, he wasn't exactly happy when, the day Jay disappeared 4 years ago, they were getting a new proxy.

He didn't want to be around people.

He sucked it up, though, changing into some clean clothes and slipping on his mask and making his way downstairs.

~~~

Skully stood beside the Øperator, looking around at the house itself. It was more like a mansion, honestly. Both were waiting on the other proxies...he had no idea what had happened to Tim or Brian, but he was determined to find out for himself. He didn't care what he had to do.
He busied himself by looking at what was provided already.

Toby bounded down the stairs with the others, "Masky!! Aren't you excited?! Another one!!" he said happily with a little giggle. Tim grumbled, "No. Whenever we meet new proxies they turn out annoying."

Hoodie chuckled at them a bit, "Leave him be, Toby...eye forward." he reminded him. They all stood in a row, Tim leading, then Toby, then Kate, and finally Brian. They all stood before the new proxy.
When Tim looked at this new proxy he felt something..weird. Like he knew who he really was under the mask. And the new proxy looked back the same way.

Slender motioned to Jay, "Everyone, this is Skully....he will be bunking with Toby. Skully, this is the first in command, Masky, then second in command, Hoodie, and then Kate and Toby." he introduced.
Masky just bowed his head respectfully, watching this new proxy closely. He was...someone. He knew him from somewhere.

"Do you all do the creepy quiet thing? Or just him?" Skully asked, making Tim glare a bit through his mask. Slender chuckled softly, "They can be quite...noisy. Give them time, they won't be quiet anymore."

Skully just chuckled and nodded as Toby stepped forward and personally introduced himself. He just smiled, "Nice to meet you. How long have you been here?" he asked.

Slender checked the time and retreated to the kitchen to make everyone some dinner.
Masky watched Slender disappear before tapping on Hoodie's shoulder and nodding to outside so they could talk while Skully chatted with Toby and Kate.

He knew. He knew who 'Masky' was. But, he just couldn't make himself say it...

Brian walked outside with Tim, thinking about how familiar that new proxy was. Tim waited until the door was closed to pull his mask off, "Did that new proxy seem familiar to you at all?" he asked, "because I think I know who that is..."

Brian nodded and looked at him for a moment, "...are you okay...?" he asked. He knew who he thought that was.
Tim took a deep breath, "Maybe...I don't know. I've gone so long with the guilt that Jay died at...his hands. All because of me...I just don't know what to do." he said. Brian was someone he could trust, someone he could be completely honest with.

Brian offered him a hug, which Tim accepted happily, "Hey...its okay. We could confront him...?" he asked. Tim nodded, "Yeah...I think we should."

Skully walked to his new room with Toby. It was surprisingly clean...Toby seemed so..chaotic. He started unpacking and placed a framed picture of himself, Tim, Alex, and Brian on the dresser.
Toby saw the picture and felt confused, "Hey..that's...Tim? And Brian?" he asked.

Jay looked over, "Yeah...I knew them from before..."
Toby smiled, "Wow! How cool...do they know its you?" Jay shook his head and smiled, "No...but I'm gonna talk to them myself." he said, sighing and looking rather sad, "I'm gonna go find Tim. I'll be back in a bit." he said, walking out.

Tim walked with Brian, feeling overwhelmed by everything. Jay was alive and okay...it made him want to smile. He just wanted to hug him and beg for forgiveness and never let him out of his sight again. As they turned, he saw Jay walked towards them and froze up a bit. What would he even say? What could he say?

Jay saw him and walked up to him, "Hey...is there...somewhere we can talk?" he asked. Tim nodded, "Yeah...uh..come with me." he said, leading him to an empty room. Jay followed, walking with him into the empty room and closing the door. He pulled off his mask as well.

Tim did the same as him, just starting at him for a moment. It really was him...he was okay.
Jay rushed to him and kissed him hard, in a nearly teeth-shattering kiss. He wanted to feel him. He wanted to make sure this wasn't some kind of sick trick.

Tim kissed back, stumbling back and against the wall. He had craved his touch for so long...he missed his kiss for so long. Jay grabbed his legs, lifting him up and holding him against the wall. He moaned into the kiss, squeezing his hips softly.

He held him as close as he could, moaning into the kiss as well and tugging his hair a bit. Jay nipped at his lips, making them swollen and moving to bite at his neck. Tim panted and moaned, squeezing his thighs around him while Jay pulled on his clothes and whined softly.

Tim nodded and moaned, letting Jay have full control over him and the situation. He didn't even say anything, he was too busy making up for lost time as he kissed down his chest and pulled on the hem of his pants.
Tim raised his hips to let him slide his pants off, beginning to let his mind wander a bit. He wasn't even sure they locked the door behind them.

Jay slid them down. He didn't care if they locked the door or not. He didn't care about anything else anymore. He had Tim back and all to himself, at least for right now. That's all that mattered.

Tim watched him and smiled, blushing softly. His heart was pounding with excitement. He didn't care if anyone caught them...he just didn't want to get cock-blocked.
He kissed him hard, pulling down his boxers in one swift motion and holding him as close as possible. Tim kissed back and blushed more, wrapping his arms around his neck.

Jay kissed him hard again, "Tell me you love me...?" he asked softly as he undid his own pants and boxers.
"I do love you..." he panted, "God, I love you so much, I missed you." he breathed.

He smiled widely, "I love you too...oh my God, I love you. How long has it been?" he asked, nodding down to his unmentionables.
Tim looked up, blinking in surprise. "Uh...since Slender took me to the mansion...you.know I fell for you the moment I saw you." he said with a giggle and a small twitch, still trying to process the whole situation. ((Pause the story Lol. Funny fact about this line! I was doing an rp with someone and I actually got this rp confused with a Toby x Tim rp Haha. This was a Toby line but I worked it in. :P))

Jay smiled and chuckled softly, "I know, love. How long as it been since you bottomed?" he asked. Tim smiled and blushed, "Last time we were together..." he said softly, "And...you?"
He smiled at him, "Same." Tim smiled and blushed more, "I thought about you. A lot. But...it was never the same."

Jay smiled and kissed him, soft and quick, before pushing his fingers in his mouth softly. Tim hummed and blushed while Jay waited until they were wet enough to bring them down and rub against his rim, making Tim blush more and bite his lip.

Jay gently thrusted his fingers, making Tim gasp and moan and rock back on his fingers. Once he was stretched enough, he pulled them out and lined himself up while pushing softly against his entrance.

Tim looked up and moaned softly, kissing back when Jay kissed him and pushed in slowly.
He gave him a minute to adjust before gently and slowly thrusting in and out of him, making Tim gasp and moan, "Jay..." he whined.

He smiled and kissed his throat, making sure to leave a fee dark hickeys, "Tim~..." he growled softly.
Tim arched up to the touch and moaned. Jay smirked and sped up, doing all he could to make him feel good.

Tim moaned louder and wrapped his arms and legs around him while Jay sped up and moaned louder as well. Neither of them cared if anyone heard.
He gasped and moaned louder, "Harder, please!~" he begged.
Jay smirked a bit, thrusting harder and faster.

Brian had walked by the spare room, smiling a bit. He kept going towards his room, not interested in listening in.

Tim gasped and moaned louder, scratching his back as he felt the knot building up quickly. Jay panted, feeling close. He thrusted faster and harder, thrusts beginning to get sloppy.
"'M close!~" Tim cried out, moaning and gasping. Jay squeezed his waist, "Me too!~" he groaned.

Tim squeezed around him and moaned loudly, arching up. He cried out, "Jay!~" as he came harder then he had in a while. Not long after, in fact almost immediately, Jay came into him while moaning loudly, squeezing him tightly.

Tim moaned at the feeling, clinging to him and panting. Thankfully no one had heard them, except for Brian (And Slenderman knew too) but Tim was sure they other two would find out somehow.

After Jay pulled out, they laid there in comfortable silence. Tim felt so...happy that Jay was back. Sure, he got stuck in this mess and it was probably his fault, but at least they could be together again.
Jay looked over at Tim, a smile on his face. "I can't believe we both ended up here...after everything, we still ended up close together." he said.

Tim chuckled a bit, "Yeah...fate knows just what to do. God, its been four years..." he said. "Four years of..." he sighed and pushed away any bad feelings. He wouldn't ruin their moment.
Jay smiled sadly, "I know you blame yourself...but, honestly, I don't blame you. No one does." he reassured.

Tim smiled and hugged him close, praying that this wasn't another hallucination or bad dream. He needed it to be real. Jay hugged him back and smiled, chuckling softly.

They stayed that way for maybe an hour before getting dressed. Tim groaned a bit, feeling a bit sore. He smiled at Jay, kissing him. Things wouldn't be like they were before...not for a while. But, they could at least be together again. That's all either of them had wanted.
"Want to go talk to Brian?" Tim asked, a smile on his face. Jay nodded quickly and excitedly, both of them grabbing their masks and slipping them on.

Tim led them to Brian's room, knocking softly and waiting for him to answer. He smiled when the door opened, "May we come in?" he asked, to which Brian nodded and smiled softly. He let them in and closed the door behind himself.

Jay pulled off his mask, as well as Tim and Brian. Brian just smiled before getting Jay in a bone-crushing hug. Jay grunted and chuckled, hugging back just as tightly.
They all knew they weren't going to be the same. They weren't even the same people. But, at least now they all could be together again. Brian cared about Jay, he was like a brother to him and so was Tim.
And he knew how much Tim and Jay loved one another. It was cute, honestly. The looks they would give one another, the small amounts of PDA, and the way they never seemed to have a problem with fighting.

Jay had the biggest, goofiest grin on his face. "I missed you guys so much, god." he said with a sigh.
Brian chuckled, "Well, I heard just how much you missed Tim." he teased, smirking at them a bit. Both Tim and Jay went bright red in a matter of seconds, which made Brian let out a laugh, "Hey, don't get so embarrassed. Trust me, I had a feeling it would happen."

"No...No one else heard, though...?" Jay asked. Brian shook his head, "They were downstairs helping Slendy set up for dinner." he said. Tim and Jay both let out a sigh of relief, glad that they wouldn't have to live with that embarrassment forever.
"But they will probably know already...Tim is limping." he said with a chuckle. Tim blushed and fidgeted, knowing they would notice.

Jay chuckled and nodded a bit, "Yeah..." he said softly, scratching the back of his neck. Tim blushed more and smiled, happy they were all together.
Something clicked in Brian's head, "Hey...if Jay and I did live after all of that...does that mean..he could still be alive?" he asked, tilting his head a bit. Jay and Tim looked at one another, shrugging. "I guess its possible..." Tim said, "but we shouldn't worry about that now, we should just hang out as much as we can."
Jay chuckled and nodded, "Yeah..." he said with a smile.

Slender could tell how close Tim and Jay were and he had an idea. He called Toby into his office, smiling to himself.
The ticking teen made his way in, smiling at his boss, "Hey-y Slendy! Y-You-u nee-eeded me?" he asked.

Slenderman nodded, "Would you be upset if I moved Skully to Tim's room? I discovered they are close and I figured he would feel much more at home that way." he asked. Toby smiled, "I wouldn't mind! If it makes them happy, then I don't care!" he said with a smile.

Slender nodded, "Thank you, Toby." Tony nodded and smiled before taking off. He called Skully and Masky to his office, making the two look a bit worried.

They made their way there together, Tim wincing and limping a bit. They stepped into the large office, Slender smiling at them.
"Ah, Good, you are here. Good news, Jay, you are moving to room with Tim." he said.

Both blinked in surprise. "We...are?" he asked. Slender nodded, "Lets just say some...recent..events made me change my mind." he said with a chuckle, making them both blush.
"Now, go move your stuff and meet us in the kitchen, dinner should be ready."

Jay and Tim scurried away, both smiling widely. Tim helped Jay move his stuff, thanking Toby for letting Slendy do this.
They were both so happy, getting cuddle every night they could. Brian was even happy for them.

They finished unpacking together and went downstairs. Tim tried his hardest to not seem like he was limping, but he could only do so much. Toby and Kate noticed him limping, giggling softly to themselves.
Tim flushed and sat with Jay, ignoring his discomfort. While they ate, Tim, Jay, and Brian told the others about some of their funny past stories.

After dinner Tim hummed, deciding to check if anything could have possibly been outside. He always checked. Being first in command, he had to keep his fellow proxies safe.

Thankfully, there was nothing. He smiled and close and locked the door, going to search for Jay. He found him in their room, smiling at him.

Jay smiled, turning to him, "Hey..." he said, plopping down on the bed. Tim walked over and laid with him, yawning and pulling off his mask. Jay hung his mask up and smiled at Tim, kissing him sweetly.
Tim kissed back and smiled, relaxing against Jay. The cuddled, slowly falling asleep with smiles plastered to their faces.

((Heyyyyyfluff. Hehe. And smut. Expect more. A lot more. I also like the idea of bottom Tim. I dont know why.))