A/n: everything in bold is a Hamilton reference

Sam's pov:

"I know i'm the last person you'd expect to see but I just need you to do me a favor." I say

"Sam it is great to see you you're a good man but I absolutely down right refuse to go back to that life. I've finally gotten out and made a name for myself. I'm not going back.."

"I'm not asking you to do anything that involves going back to this life I have a simple request.Please?" I begged

??? Sighed. "What do you have in mind?"

I smiled. "Thank you."

Your pov:

Lately i've been listening to Hamilton soundtrack and needless to say i'm helpless!!! I'm in love with the soundtrack Dean and my boyfriend Sam can attest to that.

While we're in the impala on the go if it's too quiet I start humming
"My shot" or  "who lives, who dies, who tells your story."
It annoys the hell out of Dean sometimes and he turns on his music.
But sam tells me he thinks its cute.

During a hunt i'm thinking of "guns and ships."

In the morning, cleaning or when. walking around the bunker I'm singing or humming "Schuyler sisters"

When i'm reading a book or doing research for a hunt. I listen to "Right hand man." 

After Sam and I have our lovey dovey couple moments Dean seems to hate so much I hum or sing a verse from "Helpless." Which is one of my all time favorites!

Sam finds it cute how I obsess over this broadway musical.
But what can I say i'm helpless for this musical.
No? Okay.
Anyways today We were New York.
The place where you can be a new man.
But we were here for a vampire case. Sam said we would go to the show after the hunt and I couldn't be more excited!! I've been streaming it on Sam's laptop but i've been dying to see the show live!
And believe me I am not throwin away my shot  to see this show. So i've put my mind at work. I've been readin, retreatin every bit of information I can if anything I was researching like I was running out of time.

I think I worried Sam because he asked me to take a break before I lose a portion of my brain.

Soon the hunt went under way and over with just as fast.
We were back at the hotel getting ready to go to the theatre. I made sure I had my phone to take a picture of Sam and I in front of the theatre. I put my most formal outfit besides my fed suit:

"Do I look ok? Is it too much? Too less?" I asked Sam.

He grabbed my waist and pulled me close with a smile and let out a chuckle.

"You look perftectly fine."

"Are you sure this would be enough?"

"Believe me you look beautiful darling." He said giving me a kiss.

"Great so we better get going! You have the tickets? You do have the tickets right?" I asked.

"Yes they are in my pocket." He pulled them out and showed me before putting them back in there safe spot.
We drove to the theatre where people were clammering to get in. The closer we got to the booth the more my heart began race. But it all went by fast. We gave the lady in the booth our tickets and soon we were in our seats waiting for the show to begin.

Soon the show was over and everyone was talking about how amazing the show was.

Me especially.

"Oh my gosh that was amazing!!!!It was better than I expected to be!! Lin was amazing at the end!!Oh my gosh I never cried so much!!"

"I would know you were crying into my jacket." Sam answered.

I automatically felt bad. "Oh baby i'm so sorry." I apologized

"No honey it's fine even though I didn't cry I understand it was an emotional musical."  He said kissing my forehead.

I blushed.

His phone went off. He sighed heavily and answered it.

"Hello...yes we're in the way....Dean seriously..we're on the way good bye Dean." Sam hung up.
"It was Dean wondering when we were getting back. But before I go I want to take you somewhere."
He took my hand and lead me to a door guarded by a guard.

"I'm sorry Sir this is restricted area." The man said.

Sam held up some sort of badge.

"Here to see an old friend of mine pretty sure he knew I was coming." Sam said.

Right then Leslie Odom Jr. Who played Aaron Burr opened the door.

"Hey they're with us otis" He said smiling.

"Oh my god...I think there was something in the burger i'm seeing Aaron Burr right now."

"C'mon in guys. Everyone is waiting for you." We followed him inside.

"So, Lin tells us that you are a big fan of Hamilton." Leslie says.

"Oh um yes I really am in fact in high school for my american history class I chose to do my class presentation on Alexander Hamilton the fact that Lin created a whole musical based off his life really amazed me I mean he hit everything on the head." I rambled.

"Well I am impressed." He said smiling.

"Mr.Odom I um wanted to tell you did show tonight you did well- everyone did well but I always found Aaron Burr as an interesting character in Alexander's life and you played him well."

"Why thank you." He opened the door to a small room to see The girls who played the Schuyler sisters. The guys who played Hercules, Lafayette and John and last but not least Lin-Manuel Miranda the man himself who played Alexander  Hamilton.

"Oh my gosh." I say smiling.

"Ah thank goodness you made it. Hi you must be (y/n), Sam has told me so much about you. My god you're beautiful better than he described you." Lin said shaking my hand.

"He talked to you about me?" I said confused.

"Oh yes in fact Sam here told me you were such a huge fan of the show and convinced me to give you a  small session for your ears only."

I looked at Sam.

"Surprise."

I hugged him tightly.

"Oh my gosh!Sam you're amazing!!!" I say.

"Well Sam here tells me your favorite song are the Schuyler sisters and Helpless." Lin says.

"Yes I love the whole soundtrack in fact I have the whole album on my phone but those are my top two."

"Well luckily for you the Schuyler sisters are more than happy to sing for you."

"Oh my gosh that's so cool!"

"Hope you don't mind but theu prefer to sing it in the order it came in so schuyler sisters goes first."

"No, no I don't mind please how ever you guys see fit." I say smiling.

We sit in a seat.

"(Y/n) (L/n) and Sam Winchester I present to you Schuyler Sisters."

I cheered and clapped.
Next came my all time favorite song.

(Media)

Hamilton/Burr/Laurens/All women (except Eliza):]
Hey hey hey hey

[Eliza (all women):]
Oh, I do I do I do I (Hey hey hey hey)
Dooo! Hey! (Hey hey hey hey)
Oh, I do I do I do I (Hey hey hey hey)
Dooo! Boy you got me (Hey hey hey)

[Eliza and women:]
Helpless!
Look into your eyes, and the sky's the limit I'm helpless!
Down for the count, and I'm drownin' in 'em

[Eliza:]
I have never been the type to try and grab the spotlight
We were at a revel with some rebels on a hot night
Laughin' at my sister as she's dazzling the room
Then you walked in and my heart went "Boom!"

I blushed remembering how I met sam...

Flashback:

It was a party at the bar for my friend.
I seen him across the room and my stomach with abrupt with butterflies.

Tryin' to catch your eye from the side of the ballroom
Everybody's dancin' and the band's top volume

[Eliza and women:]
Grind to the rhythm as we wine and dine

[Eliza (all women):]
Grab my sister, and whisper, "Yo, this one's mine." (Ooh)
My sister made her way across the room to you (Ooh)
And I got nervous, thinking "What's she gonna do?" (Ooh)
She grabbed you by the arm, I'm thinkin' "I'm through" (Ooh)
Then you look back at me and suddenly I'm

Helpless!

My friend noticed me staring at him  and went to bring him over to our table suddenly got nervous hoping she doesn't embarrass me. Suddenly our eyes connect and I felt like his eyes were sending me to cloud nine.

Oh, look at those eyes (Look into your eyes, and the sky's the limit)
Oh! Yeah, I'm helpless, I know
(Down for the count and I'm drownin' in 'em)
(I'm helpless!)
I'm so into you, I am so into you (Look into your eyes, and the sky's the limit I'm helpless!)
I know I'm down for the count and I'm drownin' in 'em

[Hamilton:]
Where are you taking me?

[Angelica:]
I'm about to change your life

[Hamilton:]
Then by all means, lead the way

[Eliza:]
Elizabeth Schuyler
It's a pleasure to meet you

[Hamilton:]
Schuyler?

[Angelica:]
My sister

[Eliza:]
Thank you for all your service

[Hamilton:]
If it takes fighting a war for us to meet, it will have been worth it

[Angelica:]
I'll leave you to it

[Eliza and women:]
One week later

[Eliza:]
I'm writin' a letter nightly
Now my life gets better, every letter that you write me
Laughin' at my sister, cuz she wants to form a harem

After meeting at the bar soon we were texting every single chance we get and calling every night before bed. I'd never felt so....Helplessly in love.

[Angelica:]
I'm just sayin', if you really loved me, you would share him

[Eliza (all women):]
Ha!
Two weeks later in the living room stressin' (stressin')
My father's stone-faced while you're asking for his blessin' (blessin')
I'm dying inside, as you wine and dine
And I'm tryin' not to cry 'cause there's nothing that your mind can't do (Ooh)
My father makes his way across the room to you (Ooh)
I panic for a second, thinking "we're through" (Ooh)
But then he shakes your hand and says "be true" (Ooh)
And you turn back to me, smiling, and I'm

I'm suddenly reminded of why I loved this song so much it reminded me of how I feel for sam. I blush and smile at the thought.

Helpless!
(Look into your eyes, and the sky's the limit)
I'm helpless, hoo
(Down for the count and I'm drownin' in 'em I'm helpless!)
Yes mommy, that boy is mine
(Look into your eyes, and the sky's the limit)
(I'm helpless!)
Helpless!
Down for the count and I'm drownin' in 'em

[Hamilton:]
Eliza, I don't have a dollar to my name
An acre of land, a troop to command, a dollop of fame
All I have's my honor, a tolerance for pain
A couple of college credits and my top-notch brain
Insane, your family brings out a different side of me
Peggy confides in me, Angelica tried to take a bite of me
No stress, my love for you is never in doubt
We'll get a little place in Harlem and we'll figure it out
I've been livin' without a family since I was a child
My father left, my mother died, I grew up buckwild
But I'll never forget my mother's face, that was real
And long as I'm alive, Eliza, swear to God
You'll never feel so…

The music paused and Sam got down on one knee in front of me.

"Oh my gosh."  I say getting teary eyed.

"(Y/n) I know that I may not have much to offer and our line of work doesn't make life easier. But I love you beyond belief and you've made me a very happy man. But I would be even happier by becoming Mrs.Winchester?" He took out a velvet box holding a beautiful ring.

I smiled and cried. "Yes!!!" I hugged him.

[Hamilton (Eliza) {all women}:]
{Helpless!} (I do I do I do I do!) Eliza...
{Helpless!} (I do I do I do I do!) I've never felt so

Sam picked me up and I giggled.

{Helpless!} (Hey, yeah, yeah!)
{Down for the count and I'm drownin' in 'em} (Down for the count and I'm)
My life is gon' be fine cuz Eliza's in it {Helpless!}

He slipped on the ring I looked up to him and smiled happily. He held my hands and smiled back.

(I look into your eyes, and the sky's the limit) {Helpless!}
(I'm) {Helpless!}
{Down for the count and I'm drownin' in 'em}

Sam cupped my cheek.

[*wedding march plays*]

[All women:]
In New York, you can be a new man…
In New York, you can be a new man…
In New York, you can be a new man…

And we kissed..

[Eliza:]
Helpless