Well, this is difficult.

I don't really like the first book. It's too cheesy, and all the characters annoy me. Even Dex! So that's out.

I like Exile a lot actually, but not my favorite.

I also really like Everblaze, but not quite as much as the next two.

I really like Neverseen, and I really like Lodestar. I could go either way.

Neverseen- I love when they're at Alluveterre and Exillium and Calla and when they start Cognate training and I really like Keefe in this book (even though he joined the Neverseen) and I even kinda liked the part when we found out about Alvar (I DON'T like Alvar, but it's a good part). And omg when Keefe found Mr. Snuggles!!!

Lodestar- Sophitz is amazing in this book, and Sandor and Grizel (Grizdor????), and I also like Keefe in this one, and even though it was so sad when Mr. Forkle died that was a really good part, and the ending was so good.

I'm going with Neverseen, but Lodestar is a close second. Neverseen is my favorite!