Bill-
-"O-oh God... Y/N-N..."
-Absolutely terrified
-You actually have to pin him down and hug him to calm him down
-You took too long, and both were prosecuted by the police
-You know all too well that Bill won't survive in prison
-But you will.

Richie-
-"That's what you get for fucking with my doll!"
-Tries to look cool
-Is actually breaking down in terror
-"Y-Y/N?! WHAT DO WE DO?!"
-You have to help him hide the body
-"H-how do you know how this works?"
-"..."
-"Y/N? Doll?"

Eddie-
-"EEW THEY'RE BLEEDING EVERYWHERE Y/N HELP ME!"
-You end up cleaning the whole thing while Eddie takes a shower
-He has no idea how you did your magic, but you did
-In thanks, he lets you cuddle with him all you like for a week

Mike-
-"... Don't fuck with me..."
-You're actually kind of scared
-He expertly "disposes" of the body
-Mike actually looses all emotion for a while
-Breaks down crying in your shoulder a bit later because of his guilt

Stan-
-Literally turns himself in
-"I fucked up. I fucked up. TAKE ME AWAY, JAIL HOES!"
-You visit him everyday, as he falls into a deep guilty sadness
-"It was just a mistake. He assaulted you."
-You've been trying to comfort him but it seems to have broken him
-All you can do is wait for his release

Beverly-
-"Guess we're murderers now, ey Y/N?"
-You have to help a bit, but both of you seem to know quite a bit in the art of body-hiding
- Neither of you ever bring it up again
-Ever
-Probably because she decided it was time to make out. Why not?

Ben-
-Expertly kills, cleans up, and disposes of the body
-"B-Benny baby?"
-A lot of psychopathic giggling
-"Yes, Y/N?"
-Did he just twitch?
-Eventually, he passes out
-He remembers nothing when he wakes up
-This is your secret now

Henry-
-Breaks down crying immediately
-"I-I didn't mean to hurt him this bad, I swear!"
-You of course help him, letting him bawl his eyes out before helping him dispose of the body
-He decides not to question how you know so much about hiding bodies
-You spend the rest of the night cuddling with the petrified bab

—