Sal: You make him a big scrapbook full of pictures of you two, ticket stubs, inside jokes and memories you two have had so far, leaving lots of blank pages for the memories to come...

——————

Brian (Q): Since he's such a good chef, you put together a recipe book of his favorite recipes, with pictures and everything.

——————

James (Murr): You made a homemade pasta dish that you two enjoyed over a candlelight dinner.

——————

Joe: You bake him a very intricate ten layer crepe cake with Italian Meringue Frosting, and decorate it with fondant decorations and lots of intricate piping.