2 | Inside the Case

Prompt: Newt shows Reader his creatures inside his suitcase, but when they try to go outside to go to bed, they find out that the exit has been blocked and Reader has to spend the night with Newt inside his case.

Requested by @DarilththeEtenal

Rated: PG-13

A/N: lol this is so cringy

* * * 

"Please, please, please, Newt?" the attractive H/C-haired female begged, giving her boyfriend puppy dog eyes.

When Newt had traveled to New York, he met Y/N, another witch from Ilvermony. Ever since then, they had been dating. However, Newt hadn't shown Y/N the case yet, and she only discovered it during the previous two weeks. 

Newt smiled, looking at Y/N's pouting face and doe eyes, and couldn't help but melt, until he regained his sense of clarity and looked back at his notebook. "Y/N, you know that I have a lot more work to do. Such as the ointment for injured Thunderbirds, and another page on the Fraphorns' best skills."

"But you always do your work alone in the case, and I want to see all of your fantastic beasts!" she whined.

"Sweetheart, I can show it to you tomorrow," he suggested, although he already knew what was coming next.

"But that's what you said yesterday!" Y/N exclaimed, giving a dejected sigh soon after. "I guess that I'm not special enough, so ordinary that you can't even show me what matters the most to you."

"You matter the most to me," Newt replied softly, causing her heart to flutter. He sighed and took a deep breath. "But anyways, if you want me to, I can show you it soon."

Beaming, turning her sad face to an excited face immediately, Y/N dragged Newt towards his case, knowing that she had won. Newt dropped his notebook, gently tore his hand out of Y/N's tight grip, and put an arm around her shoulders. He bent over and unlocked the case, climbing down into it.

"Come on!" he yelled, but his voice was a mere echo. 

 Y/N followed, giggling, and then standing silent, eyes wide in wonder. "Wow."

She saw a large bird fly above her, making a sound that sounded similar to a human huffing disapprovingly. 

"Relax, Frank, this is Y/N," Newt said soothingly next to her, raising a hand to the bird--Frank. 

"He's gorgeous," Y/N whispered. Then she reached out a hand but suddenly stopped. "May I touch him?" she asked for permission. 

Newt nodded and gently took her hand and placed it on Frank's head. 

"Hey, Frank," she said softly, petting him on the head. "Aren't you handsome?"

Frank let out a small 'squawk' as if saying 'yes'. 

"He's a Thunderbird, and I'm trying to find a healing ointment for them," Newt said, smiling at Y/N's gentleness with Frank. 

Newt also showed Y/N the rest of the Bowtruckles, although Y/N had already met Pickett multiple times since he was always with Newt. 

"They're so adorable!" she squealed. 

"Someday, you can have one of your own," he offered, enjoying her face as it lit up with happiness and excitement. 

Her face dimmed only a little bit when she realized he had said 'someday'. However, she was still extremely excited, so she exclaimed, "Thank you, Newt!"

Then he told her about the occamies, and also showed that to her. Y/N thought it was the cutest thing ever when he said, "Mummy's here."

After introducing her to his Erumpent, which was not very happy with Y/N's appearance so Newt had to put her into the large enclosure again, Newt continued showing Y/N his creatures. 

"It's like winter, but a more peaceful version," Y/N said in awe as they passed the rather snowy area. "We could ice skate one day here."

"That, my dear," Newt said, smiling at Y/N's enthusiasm, "Is an excellent idea."

They walked in the snow more.

Newt laughed along with Y/N when she plopped down in the snow and made snow angels. He looked at her strangely at first, but joined in with her when she yelled, "It's a classic Muggle tradition! It's really fun!"

Then they had a snowball fight.

"Good one, salamander!" Y/N laughed, using her affectionate nickname for him when she narrowly dodged a snowball. "Hey!" Newt had thrown a snowball splat at her, and it had stuck in her (H/L) hair. Now there were soft, fluffy white pieces of snow in her (light/dark) hair.

Y/N gave Newt a dazzling smile. Newt was awestruck by her beauty. Her (porcelain/olive/golden/caramel/ebony)-colored cheeks were red from the cold, her (straight/curly/wavy) hair was messy, and her (E/C) eyes were bright with life. She was the most beautiful thing he had ever seen.

While he was busy gawking at her beauty, she had gathered a large snowball and pelted it at his face, shaking him out of his thoughts.

Suddenly, Newt noticed that she was slightly shivering when she walked towards him. Taking off his coat, he draped it over her shoulders, over her soft white sweater.

"Let's go home. We can come back soon," Newt said, feeling the cold bite through his thin long-sleeved shirt and orange vest.

Nodding in agreement, Y/N laced her hand through Newt's as they headed back.

∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞

Letting go of Y/N's hand and taking his coat back, Newt climbed up to the entrance, Y/N not far behind him. He grabbed the handle and lifted the piece of wood, or at least attempted to. However, it would not budge.

"Hurry up, salamander, I need to pee!" Y/N joked to Newt. She really didn't.

"Sorry, it's not moving," Newt replied, half panicking until he saw Y/N's face and saw that she was kidding.

"Here, let me try," Y/N said, standing on her tippy-toes and trying to open the block of wood. Just like Newt said, it wouldn't move. She then tried pulling again and pushing. Not moving.

"You're right," she huffed.

"Guess we have to spend our night in here," he commented. "I do have a toilet in the back, though. And I can make us some tea or water with my wand."

"Good thing we have magic."

"Yep. Now, go out and feed the Occamies. You've heard me rant about them, so you know what to feed them. It's my shed," Newt instructed, getting down to business instantly.

Walking over to the Occamies, Y/N grabbed a loose ponytail tie around her wrist and put her (H/L) hair up, pinning it neatly and shaking out the un-melted snow. She swooped down to get the Occamy feeding bag. She was unaware of Newt staring at her (small/round/large) arse.

Stop being a pervert, Newt thought to himself and instantly got back to work.

Meanwhile, Y/N was feeding the Occamies with the weird stuff in Newt's bag. It smelled like fish and probably was salty too. She dropped a little bit above each Occamy's mouth, knowing from Newt's journal, which excessively talked about Occamies.

After feeding all of the creatures, since she saw that Newt wasn't nearby, she started looking for him. She couldn't see him anywhere, and it was getting dark.

Y/N decided to go head towards Frank, who was circling above a large hill not very far from her. But as soon as she reached its peak, it was getting dark and Frank was out of sight after she said, "Lumos."

She saw Newt's back turned to her as if he as preparing for something. As soon as she said, "Hey," he jumped, startled.

"Hey, sweetheart," Newt replied, gently taking her hand and smiling. "Come on, I've got something prepared for you."

She saw a few lights behind him, and saw that they were candles, placed delicately inside jars that were on a large blanket. Two other blankets were also there, but smaller. Then she saw the food, almost as much as a feast.

"You-you did this all for me?" she whispered, tearing up.

"Of course, Y/N," he replied, smiling, "The reason I kept on postponing it was because I needed time to get it ready, and I never had enough time. But today was a special opportunity, and since the case—the case was locked, I—I thought that you might like this."

Y/N couldn't control herself. She launched into Newt's arms, hugging him. "Thank you," she mumbled, "For everything."
Newt only smiled and sat down with Y/N. They ate the food.

Soon, the last bit of light from the sky fell, so the only glow in the darkness were the candles, the stars, and the moon. Y/N used her wand to clear the food and yawned.

"Let's go to bed," Newt said, while Y/N settled down next to him in the other smaller blanket, looking up at the sky.

"The stars are so bright," she commented. Her (H/L) hair was fanned out near her head in different directions. "The sky is so beautiful."

"Not as beautiful as you," he mumbled, brushing back a loose strand of hair on her cheek. His closeness made her breath hitch. Newt moved closer to her, angling her face towards him. Tilting her face so their noses wouldn't brush, Y/N gently captured Newt's mouth between her lips. She could feel him taking control and flipping her so he was on top. His lips sensually moved against hers. He darted his tongue into her mouth slowly and tasted her.

Only stopping when pulling away for breath, their make-out session was lengthy. However, this time was different from other times. Although it was stilled filled with love, this time was something more. Once when Y/N glanced at Newt's eyes, she saw that the blue orbs had darkened and the pupil was dilated. He was panting with lust.

Slowly, she could feel his hand reaching for her sweater and lifting it, messing up her hair even more. She was now only in her brassiere. Y/N ran a hand through Newt's soft, fluffy hair, tugging it slightly, causing him to moan slightly.

She was going to give it to this man. She loved him so much, and she knew that he loved her. Losing her virginity to him wouldn't be a mistake.

Suddenly, a slight commotion caused Y/N to pull away from Newt. It was Pickett and his Bowtruckle friends, and Frank squawking above them as if saying 'keep it appropriate, children are trying to enjoy an evening here'.

The Bowtruckles were all clapping their leaf-hands together.

Laughing, Y/N pulled on her sweater and said to a protesting Newt, "I think we better leave that for tomorrow."

Newt smiled. After a few moments of silence, he said, "You know that I love you, right?"

"Of course I do," she replied, softly brushing his hair with her finger, "And I love you too."

The next day, when the case was finally unlocked, Y/N discovered that Newt had been the one to set a charm that disabled anyone from going outside the case until the next day. But oh well. It wasn't exactly what Y/N thought they would spend the evening (she thought that they would drink hot chocolate and everything), but it was even better.