Sarah Paulson imagine for Luke :)

"Saaaarah, do we have to?" you whine as Sarah grins and pulls out a horror movie, Sinister. She winks and nods before going to put the movie into the DVD player. You sigh and sit on the couch, causing her to laugh at you and sit beside you, wrapping her arms around your waist. She snuggles her face into your neck and kisses it, chuckling lightly before pulling away.

"How are you dating a woman who acts in a horror based TV series, yet you can't even handle a simple horror movie?" she teases, grinning at you. You shake your head and playfully roll your eyes.

"Well, I don't have to be scared if I've got you here to protect me," you say, as if it's the most obvious thing in the world. She chuckles and presses play. The two of you turn your attention to the movie.

Most horror movies that Sarah makes you watch don't start off too horribly right off the bat. However, this one opens with a family being hanged on a tree. You gasp and immediately cover your eyes.

"Luke! It's really not that bad, is it?" Sarah teases. You uncover your eyes and look at her.

"N-No, I'm fine," you lie. "Let's just watch the movie," you force a smile and wrap your arms around Sarah as she leans into you. You turn your attention back to the film.

You're able to hide your fear for most of the time, however, one scene makes you verbally cry out and cover your eyes.

"Shit! Luke, are you okay?" Sarah asks. You feel her warm, soft hands remove yours from your eyes and, as the two of you make eye contact, you smile softly at her.

"I'm fine. Let's just finish it okay?"

Sarah smiles at you. "It's okay Luke, if you don't wanna watch it, I understand."

"No, I'll manage," you insist. "I know you've been wanting to watch it."

Sarah nods and you end up positioning yourself so your head is in her lap and she's running her fingers through your hair. You smile up at her end, finally, you two finish the movie.

"See? That wasn't so bad now was it?" Sarah asks once the end credits are rolling.

"No, I guess not," you admit.

A giant grin spreads across her face. "Great! Because now, it's time to watch the second one!"