I returned in the same dull room I once left. There, were my friends. Including Jeff; who looked like a living corpse.
"You're back." Jane said, uneasy.
"Back, but you also failed." Kate growled
"And we saw the whole thing." BEN says while giving me frown.
"We're not mad because Sharon confessed. I mean- you made things clear that you don't love her. But we're upset at the fact you failed the test." Jane mumbled as she looked down at her feet.
"I wasn't going to kill my bestfriend. I wasn't going to kill the only person who knew I existed! I'm not some monster!" I yell, frustrated with the three.
"Are you saying we're monsters?! Well?! Are you!?" Kate said marching up to me.
"No! You're not monsters! You're- you're still people! People with hearts! People's whose hearts have been coated in black and locked away! You killed for power because you're cowards! You're all scared and need to be controlled- because you feel as if you'll go mad if you're not! You guys- you killed the only people you loved left, because you think you have no choice! You do! You have choices! Decisions to make- why do you think I chose to fail!" I yell getting all up in her face. She backs down.
"Ann, take Jeffery away. He doesn't need to see her execution, much less kill her himself." Slender said softly.
"N-no.." Jeff cried. We all looked up- his eyes were filled with pain. Ann pulled out a needle and injected him again.
"I-I don't want to leave her-!" He moans.
"Jeff- remember the plan." BEN said nodding.
"What plan?" Slender man stepped in.
"It's none of your concern- Slender.." Jeff coughs up.
"All you need to know is (Y/N) won't die- I won't die- she's my best friend!" He starts moving out his wheelchair.
"Jeff, sit down!" Ann says.
"No-! (Y/N)! Don't leave me!!" He continues to sob. I walk up to his fragile body and touch his cheek.
"Jeff, I'm sorry. I've never been good at keeping my word.. But look at it this way- you can live. Live for me- it's going to be fine." I wipe the tears falling from his face.
"N-no-! (Y/N)! PLEASE NO-!"
"Don't make this harder than it already is Jeff!" I scream through my shaky voice.
"Goodbye.." I whisper.
I move away and nod at Ann. She smiles sympathetically and pushes Jeffery out the room. I could hear his screams and wails through the walls- this is the last time I'll ever see him.

I turn to Slender man.
"I'm ready." He nods and tells me to meet me outside, behind the mansion in the dark corridor. He leaves and now it's just me, Jane, Kate and BEN.
"You're a good person (Y/N). It wasn't your fault you didn't complete the mission. Your heart isn't evil. Not like us. No- you're 100% good." Kate said smiling. I haven't seen that smile. It looked so genuine and pure.
"The times we've had together- I'll never forget." Jane says sniffling and slowly, she takes off her mask.
"I just want to see you with my own two eyes.. I'll miss you." She's hugs me tightly, crying.
"(Y/N), this plan I have can go both ways. If it fails- then you will truly die. But.. If it works. There may be a happy ending after all." BEN says smiling.
"What ever it is, I trust you." I respond and hug him.
"Don't forget to tell the others, that I love them." I continue.
"We won't. Don't worry!" Jane smiles, trying to catch her shallow breaths.
"Well.." I walk towards the doors.
"This is goodbye." I look back and smile. I'll never forget their faces.
"Goodbye (Y/N).." The three say. Their voices sound heartbroken...either way. It's time. I open the doors, and shut them behind me.

As I walk to the back corridor, I see Slender, Ann, and Mr.Creepypasta.
"I come to every execution. It's a shame to see such a valuable member in training leave." Mr.Creepypasta says. This time, he seems more serious about matters. He's not as silly as when I first met him.
"You've done good (Y/N). There is no doubt in my mind we'll miss you." Slender man says.
"Jeffery is doing fine. Would you like me to say anything to him once I attend to his wounds after this?" Ann asks.
"Just say.. Thank you." I smile. Ann does too. She seems more human now that I got to know her. The hate inside me is gone.
"I know this may seem weird, child, but the execution is beheading. We keep the heads of every child whose tried but failed to be a Creepypasta. It's almost like a
memory of them." Slender says.
"It's fine.. Doesn't matter to me."
"Excellent. Then we shall start." Mr.Creepypasta says. He pulls out a long chair- kind of like the ones you'd see if you were at a dentists office. I lay down on the medical chair and prepare for my death.
"Usually the mentor does the beheading.. But obviously we can not allow that. So, Mr.Creepypasta shall do the honors." Ann says.
I can see the king grab an ax that has dried blood.
"We'll miss you child." Slender man says.
"I'll miss you all too." I say softly; trying not to cry.
"Any last words?" Ann asks. I think for a second..
"Never more shall I live in despair, for my gratitude has been granted upon you all. I wish you best of luck, my reign shall live on in the hearts of this land, I'll miss you." I whisper.
"You're too good (Y/N). No way someone so pure can live with us." Ann said holding back tears. I smiled. I've left my mark on the souls of my fellow friends. That's the greatest wish of all.
Mr.Creepypasta raised his ax- my last thoughts will be of Jeff. My friend. My soulmate. Oh how my love for him will remain in his heart.
He swung down- coming at my neck- I closed my eyes.

"STOP!!!" I open my eyes- the ax, centimeters away from my face. I look at the three to see them looking at something to the right of me. I turn my head- and there was Jeff. He looked much healthier.
"You can't kill her!" He yelled.
"Jeff.." I say softly.
"We must Jeffery. If we don't, you die." Ann said.

"You killed all the other trainees because of failure! Because they weren't capable of being one of us! So they had to be sent back to the Overworld! A long time ago- when you captured the first trainee, you didn't kill him! Because it wasn't a rule yet- so he returned to the Overworld and told everyone about the first Creepypasta's. People discovered about us- so you knew that if you sent trainees back to the Overworld people would find out about us- so now it became a rule to kill all trainees, right?!"
"Where are you going with this boy?" Mr.Creepypasta asked.
"What I'm saying- is all the trainees you have killed were evil! You even said (Y/N) was 100% pure- so you can't kill her! It says so right here!" Jeff pulled out an old wrinkly paper. It looked like the Bill of Rights, listing amendments. But this was for the Underworld.
"Amendment 17- any trainee who fails the five sacred tests of the proxy's must be executed. If there happens to be a time where a trainee isn't beheaded- it must be souly for the purpose of being pure, and shall be able to return to his home; only if he vows to never speak a word of the Creepypasta Underworld, after he or she signs the contract." Jeff says with determination.
"Damn. I forgot about that." Mr.Creepypasta says.
"Boys got a point. The girl's pure. Can't kill her. I suppose she can return to her world." He finishes. I bolt up- filled with such happiness and run over to Jeff, tackling him in a hug.
"Slender man, do you have a contract she can sign?" Ann asks.
"Slender may not, but I do. I carry all contracts around me, at all times. It's a rule, fortunately." Mr.Creepypasta says grabbing a brief case and pulling out a document.
"Sign here, love." Ann says bringing the paper and giving me a pen.
"Basically you can't say a word about us after you sign this. Sharon already knows about what happened to you- but thankfully you didn't say it was another dimension." she said.
"Ye-yes! I agree!" I quickly sign the contract.
"I-is it over!?" Jeff asks smiling.
"Yes, surprisingly." Slender says. Me and Jeff embrace each other tightly- but then I remember.
"Jeff- you're still sick!" I say- excitement decreasing.
"Oh- that? Yeah. Guess what else the Bill says." Jeff says smirking. He lets go and looks at Mr.Creepypasta.
"Amendment 1- If a Creepypasta's life is on the line due to any other reason besides conflict between another creepypasta or human- he or she may be able to resign from his or her position. Meaning they may return to being human once more if they vow to again, never speak of our world to the public." They all look at him. He can't possible mean-

"I Quit! I'm done being a Creepypasta!" He says brightly.
Mr.Creepypasta looks at him and smiles.
"Son, you found the other choice. Of course, only an idiot would've picked that choice but, love makes you do crazy things, doesn't it?" Mr.Creepypasta says.
"Hell yeah it does."Jeff responds while Mr.Creepypasta hands him another contract. I blush. But wait- he couldn't possibly mean love- love. Could he?

Jeff hesitates to sign the contract- and that's when we heard thousands of footsteps all running to- us?! I turn around and see BEN, Sally, Clockwork, Jane, Jill, Puppeteer, Dr.Smiley- everyone.
"You'd think you'd leave without saying goodbye? Idiot!" BEN says leading the stampede. They all stop smiling at us, some crying.
"G-guys.." I say.
"This was the plan (Y/N). The Happily Ever After you've wanted. Jeff becomes human- and he's cured. You live- so both of you can finally live together. But not here- up there." BEN says pointing to the Overworld.
"Sign it.. Sign it, sign it, sign it!" Everyone starts chanting those words. Jeff smiles brightly and leaves his signature on the contract

"It's not over." Jeffery turns to me and blushes.
"I remember how I felt, the first time I saw you. There was something about you that I couldn't forget. Maybe it was your eyes, or your irresistible smile- all the things that I have come to know so well. But whatever it was, I remember that it drew me in and took hold of me in a way I couldn't ignore. Now when I look at you, I see someone who's become incredibly important in my life. Yet there are still those moments when I feel the mystery, the charm, the same invisible powers pulling me to you- just as it did when we first met. (Y/N) (L/N), I love you so much. I finally was able to realize that when you were about to leave me. I can't see a world without you.. So.. I have to ask. Will you be my girlfriend?" Jeff asked. This time I couldn't hold back the tears. They kept falling and falling, my heart is filled with so much joy-

"Yes! Yes!! A million times yes!!" I say excitedly. I jump in his arms and kiss him passionately. His soft lips touched mine and our tongues intertwined together, dancing. I ran my fingers through his black hair, as his hands slide to my waist. We separate; a string of saliva connecting from my lips to his.
"I love you Jeffery Woods." I whisper under my breath.
"I love you too, (Y/N). I love you so much." I laugh and kiss him again.

I could hear all the Creepypasta's cheering, and whooing at us. We laugh at the crowd, but then we see our bodies are becoming translucent, shimmering in a gold bright light as we float higher to sky. We're going home; to the Overworld. The cheers can still be heard as we start disappearing in each other's arms. We both looked below and smiled. We may be leaving them, but they're our family. And family stays in each other's hearts. We look at each other and smile brighter than before. The light reached our neck. But before we completely vanished, I looked at Jeffery and said,
"I Found You."

We were gone;