Long ago, two brothers fought.

The corrupted one, sealed the other in stone.

Dream had been frantic when Nightmare returned, to the frightful moment of Nightmare killing the villagers after eating the apples.

At least this is what Dream thought had happened.

He would have been even more Broken to realize Nightmare had never returned.

That the cursed figure was an intruder.

Hate laughed as he tormented the multiverse using Nightmares name.

OoOoO

It was a shock to Blues system when he heard of Nightmare, or rather the False Nightmare.

It took many years on one of the many reasons Dream started the group with Ink.

A horrendous being.

The tree of feelings dead.

The Villagers Dead.

Sure he hadn't liked there abuses toward him, but.. killing them?!

Dream sealed in stone.

Once home he'd collapsed brokenly in his room, and cried.

And cried some more.

He was glad now he'd hid his original identity, the only people that knew now were Stretch and Error.

The name Nightmare was ever tainted now.

Stretch could only comfort Blue on this earth shattering moment.

After all, not everyone found out someone stole there identity is such a horrible way.