Jeff the Killer:

1st Place- Forgive And Forget Me by XxsilverlollipopXD

2nd Place- The Lion Falls for the Lamb by xXToxicValentineXx

3rd Place- His Name Was Jeff by -BlondieBae-

CreepyPasta in General:

1st- 

2nd- I Am The Pasta Queen by @ZealousOtaku12 

3rd- Ask Some CreepyPastas by Bookwormthe13th

Extra Awards:

Best Written- The Lion Falls for the Lamb by xXToxicValentineXx

Favorite Character- The Lion Falls for the Lamb by @xXToxicValentineXx