Jeff the Killer:

1st Place- Dear My Sanity by XxsilverlollipopXD

2nd Place- Madison the Killer by datackermanbooty

3rd Place- His Name Was Jeff by -BlondieBae-

BEN Drowned:

1st Place- BEN Drowned by KillerHeartsRadio15

CreepyPasta in General:

2nd Place- Dead Is My Sanity by Lonely-Rogue

Extra Awards:

Favorite Character- Dear My Sanity by  by KillerHeartsRadio15

Best Written- Dear My Sanity by XxsilverlollipopXD

Best Killing Scenes- Blood Lust by datackermanbooty

(Others to be found and listed)