Jeff the Killer: 

1st Place- Sincerely Me by XxsilverlollipopXD

2nd Place- Sweet Insomnia by xXDarkQueenXxRei

3rd Place- His Name Was Jeff by -BlondieBae-

Ticci Toby:

1st Place- Love Hurts Unless You're Too Numb To Feel It by -We_Only_Live_Once-

2nd Place- Insanity and Waffles by @dsyfunctional_bxtch 

3rd Place- Twitchy Love by 21YEET

CreepyPasta in General:

1st Place- OX Killings by @alliecantwrite 

2nd Place- It's His Orders by 0Yours-Truly0

3rd Place- The Eternal Forest by Charlie_4Evah