Jeff the Killer:

1st Place- Dead But Still Living by -BlondieBae-

2nd Place- My Smile Is You by @Goldendarkness_ 

3rd Place- The Day It All Changed by ErinLSW 

CreepyPasta in General:

1st Place- Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios by @ShyCreeper 

2nd Place- I Am The Pasta Queen by @ZealousOtaku12

3rd Place- Monsters Lurk Here @ZealousOtaku12