Aaron Burr - Wendigo, he has antlers and is rather skinny compared to everyone else. And occasionally, you'll believe you see his skull through his skin, but think you're going mad. Well, you're not. He does have the capability to show his skull.
(This is what Aaron looks like if he shifts)

Hercules Mulligan - Orc, he is rather attractive for his kind. His jaw isn't oversized and full of ugly teeth, but he does have the features of an Orc. His lower canines do pop out of his jaw, but they're only slightly larger than a natural human size.

Alexander Hamilton - Vampire, his fangs are rather detectable if he smiles. His completion is rather pale compared to everyone else's, but he is able to be in the sunlight. Alexander does get the craving for blood from time to time, other than that; he eats normal food like you an I.

Marquis de Lafayette - Werewolf (You're welcome Luna, I was gonna switch Laf and Alex-), He does have a full werewolf fork and only a partly shifted form. When partly shifted, he has ears, tail and rather sharp fangs. He wouldn't harm a soul though! He can control his shifting, just.. not on full moons. When Lafayette is shifted fully, he is a wolf, obviously. Only, he's much larger than your average wolf. His forepaws have five toes instead of four and his hind paws have four toes. He had a thick pelt and a much more muscular build.

Thomas Jefferson - Werewolf, the same as Lafayette. Only, when he's transformed, he's a pale-gray color. While Lafayette is a pure black wolf.

James Madison - Wendigo, he's got the hands of a skeleton and a tail, but no antlers like Aaron. He can shift into a rather unnerving creature, but he'll still be kind and gentle as he always is. The creature has a skull for a face, and fur covers the majority of its body. The feet are hooves on his hind legs and hand-like paws/claws are on his front legs. He can stand up straight or walk on all fours.
(Here's his face btw when he's shifted)

King George III - Dark Elf, his skin is a light-grayish color and he has mesmerizing blue eyes. His features include rather sharp-looking ears and chiseled jawline. Being a Dark Elf, he can cast spells and curses. He looses his temper easily, so, be careful not to get on his bad side. We don't want you cursed, now do we?

Charles Lee - Vampire, his eyes tend to flash a deep crimson color when he's frustrated/angry/stressed. Or, when he's craving blood. In any case, you've been warned if you see the color. Charles is rather charming but he can be highly shy. Careful not to get mixed up with him, he tends to get into a lot of trouble.

Samuel Seabury - Weredog, like a werewolf but only a dog. He is much smaller in size when shifted and has beautiful, white fur. Black swirls run up his legs and curls round his muzzle and ears, signifying he's not a werewolf. Werewolves are much larger and more muscular. He keeps great company and when only half shifted, has ears and a tail; they're white as if he were shifted.

George Washington - Orc, he also has rather attractive features. His teeth aren't too large nor too small, and he has a well built, muscular frame. He's an extremely gentle being though and his expression is usually calm.

Peggy Schuyler - Banshee, banshees are known to wail in the early morning about the death of someone to come. Peggy occasionally does this, but not often. She usually looks like she's been crying though, and has puffy eyes. Tears usually well in her eyes but this is normal for her kind, so don't fret. Peggy can get easily annoyed though if this is brought up. It's best to leave the topic alone.

Angelica Schuyler - Dark Elf, she's a darkish color like KG3, but brown. (I'm not being racist, I'm just saying her color) She has sharp ears just as he kind normally would, and she's got a narrow face her expression is usually blank and she can be set off easily, remember not to mess with her. Y'know.. curses.

Elizabeth Schuyler - Witch, she doesn't have a pointy nose or chin. She does tend to wear dresses that stop just about the knee. A distinct giveaway about being a witch though, is that you can see spirits following her around that and her constant need for making potions; she considers them art.

Philip Hamilton - Weredog, he's similar to Samuel but his pelt is a soft, mocha color when shifted. He's usually half shifted and has his tail and ears, but there are those rare chances he'll stay with his human form. He tends to avoid Thomas since he frightened him, but he'll never admit to that.

John Laurens - Ragdoll, John's mouth and limbs are sewn to him. He can come off as creepy but he's very sweet if you give him a chance. He can't really feel pain but he does have human skin, which is probably why people find him creepy... you know, since his limbs are stitched to him. He has a tendency to fall apart, literally. But he carried stitches/eyeing around with him as well as a needle, so he can put himself back together.

(I think I got everyone?)

{*~Scenario One~*}

You were a {Mythical Creature/Supernatural being} and were sent away by your parents, who were mortal. They thought you were dangerous and strange.

You were shipped off to the middle of no where in a new town, where everyone was shady. Since you didn't trust anyone there, you left to the beach. It was quiet and peaceful there, and hardly anyone was around so you were left to yourself. And you enjoyed that, strangely enough.

You eventually found {Crush Name}, who seemed rather timid at first. You got to know them and learned that they were.... peculiar, like you. He/She guided you off somewhere and you met many more peculiar people like you, they were around your age which helped. They were all misfits, like you.

{*~Scenario Two~*}

Make it up. I'm out of brain fuel from writing down the descriptions on everyone.