President Xi Jinping's pledge to redistribute wealth brings back bad memories for luxury brands in China
Analysis by Michelle Toh, CNN Business
Updated 8:04 PM ET, Fri October 29, 2021
christies chow tai fook luxury jewelry asia intl hnk _00003024

US trade dependency China ppe Sebastian pkg intl hnk vpx_00012211.png
Decoupling from China isn't easy. Just look at the PPE market
China tech crackdown lu stout pkg intl hnk vpx_00000928.png
Beijing's master plan behind China's tech crackdown

China limits amount of time minors can play online video games (August 2021)
New Oriental Education & Technology Group Inc. headquarters in Beijing, China, on May 31, 2019. Shares of New Oriental Education & Technology Group Inc. (New Oriental), a leading provider of private educational services in China, soared on Tuesday after the company reported quarterly revenue and next-quarter guidance that topped analysts' expectations.  Imaginechina/AP
Beijing's regulatory crackdown hit stocks in China and the US
split China tech company listing
What does the future hold for Chinese companies listed in the US?
screengrab china shipping
Experts say China's economy is losing steam. Here's why
China wechat LGBTQ crackdown culver pkg intl hnk vpx_00023723.png
China widens crackdown on LGBTQ groups and content
--FILE--A Chinese nurse attends newborn babies at a hospital in Xiangyang city, central China's Hubei province, 22 February 2018. China is reported to be planning to eliminate the law that says each family can only have two children. China, the most populous nation in the world, is said to be planning to remove all limits on the number of children a family can have, according to people familiar with the matter, in what would be a historic move to end to a policy that caused many controversial disputes and left the world's second-largest economy short of labor. The State Council, China's cabinet, has commissioned research on the repercussions of ending the country's policy which has lasts roughly four decades and intends to enact the change nationwide, said the people, who asked not to be named. The leadership wants to reduce the pace of aging in China's population and remove a source of international criticism, one of the people said.  (Imaginechina via AP Images)
China to allow parents to have up to three children
christies chow tai fook luxury jewelry asia intl hnk _00003024.png
How luxury jewelry is bouncing back in Asia
FILE - In this Sept. 15, 2021, file photo, a man bicycles past an Evergrande new housing development in Beijing. The troubled Chinese developer whose struggle to avoid a multibillion-dollar debt default has rattled global financial markets wired $83.5 million on Friday, Oct. 22, 2021 to make an overdue payment to foreign bondholders, a government newspaper reported. (AP Photo/Andy Wong, File)
Evergrande avoids default but faces another deadline

Christmas trees may be hard to come by this year

China's energy crunch is hitting factories hard
In this photo released by China's Xinhua News Agency, Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou waves as she steps out of an airplane after arriving at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport in Shenzhen in southern China's Guangdong Province, Saturday, Sept. 25, 2021. A top executive from global communications giant Huawei Technologies returned to China on Saturday following what amounted to a high-stakes prisoner swap with Canada and the U.S. (Jin Liwang/Xinhua via AP)
Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou hailed a hero upon return to China
The photo shows physical imitations of cryptocurrency in Dortmund, western Germany, on January 27, 2020. (Photo by INA FASSBENDER / AFP) (Photo by INA FASSBENDER/AFP via Getty Images)
China's cryptocurrency crackdown intensifies
Security personnel form a human chain as they guard outside the Evergrande's headquarters, where people gathered to demand repayment of loans and financial products, in Shenzhen, Guangdong province, China September 13, 2021. REUTERS/David Kirton
Chinese property giant Evergrande is on the brink of default

Why there is skepticism surrounding video game 'addiction'
US trade dependency China ppe Sebastian pkg intl hnk vpx_00012211.png
Decoupling from China isn't easy. Just look at the PPE market
China tech crackdown lu stout pkg intl hnk vpx_00000928.png
Beijing's master plan behind China's tech crackdown

China limits amount of time minors can play online video games (August 2021)
New Oriental Education & Technology Group Inc. headquarters in Beijing, China, on May 31, 2019. Shares of New Oriental Education & Technology Group Inc. (New Oriental), a leading provider of private educational services in China, soared on Tuesday after the company reported quarterly revenue and next-quarter guidance that topped analysts' expectations.  Imaginechina/AP
Beijing's regulatory crackdown hit stocks in China and the US
split China tech company listing
What does the future hold for Chinese companies listed in the US?
screengrab china shipping
Experts say China's economy is losing steam. Here's why
China wechat LGBTQ crackdown culver pkg intl hnk vpx_00023723.png
China widens crackdown on LGBTQ groups and content
--FILE--A Chinese nurse attends newborn babies at a hospital in Xiangyang city, central China's Hubei province, 22 February 2018. China is reported to be planning to eliminate the law that says each family can only have two children. China, the most populous nation in the world, is said to be planning to remove all limits on the number of children a family can have, according to people familiar with the matter, in what would be a historic move to end to a policy that caused many controversial disputes and left the world's second-largest economy short of labor. The State Council, China's cabinet, has commissioned research on the repercussions of ending the country's policy which has lasts roughly four decades and intends to enact the change nationwide, said the people, who asked not to be named. The leadership wants to reduce the pace of aging in China's population and remove a source of international criticism, one of the people said.  (Imaginechina via AP Images)
China to allow parents to have up to three children
christies chow tai fook luxury jewelry asia intl hnk _00003024.png
How luxury jewelry is bouncing back in Asia
FILE - In this Sept. 15, 2021, file photo, a man bicycles past an Evergrande new housing development in Beijing. The troubled Chinese developer whose struggle to avoid a multibillion-dollar debt default has rattled global financial markets wired $83.5 million on Friday, Oct. 22, 2021 to make an overdue payment to foreign bondholders, a government newspaper reported. (AP Photo/Andy Wong, File)
Evergrande avoids default but faces another deadline

Christmas trees may be hard to come by this year

China's energy crunch is hitting factories hard
In this photo released by China's Xinhua News Agency, Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou waves as she steps out of an airplane after arriving at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport in Shenzhen in southern China's Guangdong Province, Saturday, Sept. 25, 2021. A top executive from global communications giant Huawei Technologies returned to China on Saturday following what amounted to a high-stakes prisoner swap with Canada and the U.S. (Jin Liwang/Xinhua via AP)
Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou hailed a hero upon return to China
The photo shows physical imitations of cryptocurrency in Dortmund, western Germany, on January 27, 2020. (Photo by INA FASSBENDER / AFP) (Photo by INA FASSBENDER/AFP via Getty Images)
China's cryptocurrency crackdown intensifies
Security personnel form a human chain as they guard outside the Evergrande's headquarters, where people gathered to demand repayment of loans and financial products, in Shenzhen, Guangdong province, China September 13, 2021. REUTERS/David Kirton
Chinese property giant Evergrande is on the brink of default

Why there is skepticism surrounding video game 'addiction'
Hong Kong (CNN Business)Chinese President Xi Jinping's national campaign for "common prosperity" has cast a shadow over an industry that counts the country as one of its biggest markets: luxury goods.

Xi's push to redistribute wealth in the world's second-largest economy has unsettled some luxury market investors. The sector still bears scars from a sweeping government crackdown on corruption several years ago and is now relying on Chinese consumers more than ever.
Shoppers in mainland China are vital to brands such as LVMH, Hermes and Gucci. Last year, as the coronavirus pandemic took hold worldwide, China's case numbers remained relatively low and the country's share of the global luxury market roughly doubled, according to consultancy Bain. The firm predicts that China will become the world's biggest market by 2025, overtaking Europe and the United States.
The latest government initiative — which coincides with a regulatory crackdown on industries from technology and education to gaming and entertainment — has raised concerns. But experts are divided on whether "common prosperity" will hurt luxury sales, which total hundreds of billions of dollars a year.
China's luxury market boomed even as global sales shrank
China's luxury market boomed even as global sales shrank
Many analysts believe the campaign could actually be good for business. While Xi's plans are still taking shape, his government has made clear that it ultimately wants to raise the incomes of more households and expand the middle class. That, in turn, could help increase purchasing power and consumption.

But experts haven't ruled out the possibility of the government clamping down on signs of perceived extravagance or raising taxes on the rich, which could darken the outlook for makers of high-end handbags, shoes and jewelry.
Enter your email to receive CNN's nightcap newsletter. close dialog
CNN business Nightcap
We read all day so you don't have to.
Get our nightly newsletter for all the top business stories you need to know.

Sign Me Up
By subscribing you agree to our
privacy policy.

"Initially when it was announced, people panicked," Zuzanna Pusz, a UBS analyst, said of the "common prosperity" pledge. "And the market panicked. Because everyone kind of went back with their memory to the anti-graft campaign, and how the luxury demand back then was impacted."

Some players have already taken a hit. Shares of LVMH slid 7.9% from August to September, while Kering, the owner of Gucci, fell 19.4% over the same period.
"In the past three months, the [luxury] sector has underperformed the European market ... on the back of renewed China concerns," including the wealth redistribution campaign, a flare-up in coronavirus cases and regulation, Citi analysts wrote in an October report.
The call for 'common prosperity'
Beijing has been tightening the screws on private enterprise over the past year.
But the ante was upped in August, when Xi told top leaders from the ruling Chinese Communist Party that the government should establish a system to redistribute wealth in the interest of "social fairness."
According to state news agency Xinhua, Xi said that it was "necessary" to "reasonably regulate excessively high incomes, and encourage high-income people and enterprises to return more to society." State media has suggested that the government could consider taxation or other ways of redistributing income and wealth.
Alibaba pledges $15.5 billion to help China achieve 'common prosperity'
Alibaba pledges $15.5 billion to help China achieve 'common prosperity'
Some companies have taken the hint from Beijing. In recent months, several of China's biggest tech firms have pledged to donate billions of dollars to the cause, including Alibaba (BABA) and Tencent (TCEHY). One company, Pinduoduo (PDD), even promised to hand over its entire profit for the second quarter.
There have been signs of apprehension within the luxury world. Recently, the sector has lost favor with some investors, which "suggests that short-term China-related uncertainty has been priced in," UBS analysts wrote in a September report.
"The impact of China's common prosperity initiatives on luxury consumption ... remains investors' key concern," they added.
But analysts at the Swiss bank also note that "common prosperity" is not a new concept in China.
Use of the phrase stretches back to the time of Chairman Mao Zedong, who invoked "common prosperity" when advocating for dramatic economic reforms to take power away from rich landlords and farmers, the rural elite.
Shoppers in an upscale retail plaza in Beijing in August. Many analysts believe the "common prosperity" campaign could be good for business, by raising the incomes of households and expanding the middle class.
Shoppers in an upscale retail plaza in Beijing in August. Many analysts believe the "common prosperity" campaign could be good for business, by raising the incomes of households and expanding the middle class.
In 2012, "common prosperity" was "deemed the 'fundamental principle' of Chinese socialism" at a major Communist Party gathering, noted Tao Wang, a UBS economist, in a report to clients.
Analysts at the bank also say they expect just "modest and gradual" adjustments in personal income tax and consumption tax in the next few years, suggesting that "the negative impact may be limited and not imminent."
Chinese shoppers are giving luxury brands some hope
Chinese shoppers are giving luxury brands some hope

Some top executives have addressed the issue directly.
Earlier this month, LVMH Chief Financial Officer Jean Jacques Guiony said that he was "not particularly worried or concerned with the recent announcement."
"We don't see any reason to believe that this could be detrimental to the upper middle class, affluent class that is the bulk of our customer base," he told analysts. "Therefore, this seems to us not to be negative — if not positive."
Last week, Nicolas Hieronimus, CEO of L'Oreal, which owns brands such as Giorgio Armani Beauty and Lancôme, also weighed in.
"We remain very confident for China," he said on a corporate sales call, adding that the "common prosperity" pledge would likely help make the country's middle class "wealthier and bigger, [which] is very positive for us."
A sensitive subject
Industry observers, though, have good reason to worry.
Less than a decade ago, the luxury industry was hit hard by a massive anti-corruption drive in China. The government stamped out any sign of lavish spending among officials, including on luxury goods.
The campaign, rolled out by Xi in 2012, had a dramatic impact on the sector. In 2013, mainland China's luxury market grew just 2%, compared to 7% the previous year, according to Bain.
Some fashion brands were eschewed as shoppers looked for less conspicuous logos or designs. People "don't want to just walk around with big LVs anymore," Patricia Pao, CEO of the Pao Principle, a consultant for luxury brands in China, told CNN at the time.
Shoppers lining up to enter a Louis Vuitton store in Nanjing, in east China's Jiangsu province, in August.
Shoppers lining up to enter a Louis Vuitton store in Nanjing, in east China's Jiangsu province, in August.
Premium liquor brands, such as baijiu maker Kweichow Moutai, also saw sales drop off significantly. The company later said that the campaign led to "unprecedented pressure" on the alcohol industry.
The sector is still facing regulatory concerns, and was recently hit by a sell-off in shares.
It's 53% alcohol and tastes like fire. Here's how this liquor brand took over China
It's 53% alcohol and tastes like fire. Here's how this liquor brand took over China
During the 2012 anti-corruption crusade, swanky hotels suffered, too, as officials called off banquets and conferences. Some five-star hotels at the time even asked to drop down a star, in hopes that the lower ratings would allow them to appear less opulent and retain business, Chinese state media reported.
It doesn't help that businesses ranging from the booming tech sector to private education in China have lately been targeted with another crackdown, which has spilled over into the entertainment and live-stream shopping industries.
Pusz, the UBS analyst, said that may have contributed to some unease.
"Because obviously there has been quite a bit of news flow in the market about several other industries being impacted by various measures of the Chinese government, I think there was a bit of anticipation from people, [like]: 'Okay, what if luxury comes next?'" she said.
Times have changed
Some analysts, though, think this crackdown could be different.
According to the latest estimates from Bain, shoppers in China account for 35% of all luxury sales worldwide. By 2025, the firm suggests that could shoot up to nearly 50%.
Bruno Lannes, a partner with Bain's consumer products and retail practices who is based in Shanghai, said his firm isn't changing its forecasts because of the "common prosperity" pledge.
"It's too early to say, but there is no real indication that this has a major impact, I think, on the brands," he told CNN Business.
Lannes expects the latest policy could have a "neutral" or "positive" effect on luxury consumption, particularly if incomes grow across the country as a result.
"I think it's very different from what happened [with] the anti-corruption campaign back then," he added.
Previously, many luxury brands in China were driven by the tradition of executives or officials giving or receiving gifts, which was a huge target of the campaign, Lannes noted. Now, consumption is largely "by people who consume for themselves or for their relatives," he said.
China jails former chairman of liquor giant Moutai for life for corruption
China jails former chairman of liquor giant Moutai for life for corruption
Some consumers may already be starting to hold back on spending, however.
According to LookLook, a consumer research firm that works with luxury brands, 1 in 10 respondents to a recent survey of 100 luxury buyers in China cited the government crackdown on excessive shows of wealth as a reason they were not spending as much these days.
One participant of the study, which was released in September, cited a desire to not "attract unwanted attention," according to LookLook CEO Malinda Sanna.
"We've never heard that before," she said. "I think the demand is definitely still there, but they're being cautious."
— Laura He contributed to this report.