We drive to the restaurant and it's clear that Chase knows his way around. He tells me a little about the town and his family, and I find myself actually enjoying the conversation. We get to a trendy new place with a cool, modern vibe. It's a stunning venue, decorated with neon lights and filled with the buzz of people chatting and laughing.

"Reservation for McKnight," Chase says to the maître d'.

"Ah, Mr. McKnight. This way, please," the maître d' says, leading us to our table.

Chase surprises me by pulling out my chair for me to sit down.

"Wow, Macey's right. You really are a gentleman," I tease him as I take my seat.

"I try to be," he chuckles. We peruse the menu cards in front of us, and I try to hide my disappointment when I notice that there aren't many vegetarian options.

"I guess I'll get the tofu," Chase says. "I'm a vegetarian, you know?"

"Oh, me too! I'll have the same," I say. At least we have something in common.

As the night goes on, I find myself getting more and more comfortable with Chase. He's funny, charming, and genuinely interested in getting to know me. We even discover that we have a shared love for 80s movies and spend a good chunk of the night reminiscing about our favorites. I find myself surprised by how much we have in common.

"I hate to say it, but Ashleigh is right," he says, sounding serious, disrupting the light conversation we had going. "About staying away from Will Walker. He's not a good guy, Kathryn. He really isn't."

"What's with Will and Ashleigh anyway? Are they, like, going out or something?" I ask, ignoring the "not a good guy" comment.

"Not exactly. They're more like, um, funbuddies," he states awkwardly.

"Oh. Oh." My eyes widen.

"Yeah. Seriously though, he's trouble. Always getting arrested. It's better to stay away." He says, sounding a lot like Macey. Why does everyone want me to stay away from this guy? It's only making me more curious.

"Trouble? Really?" I ask. "What kind of trouble?"

"Let's not talk about this anymore. I'd much rather talk about you," he gazes into my eyes like he did earlier this evening. "You're so beautiful."

"Um, it's late," I look down at my phone, breaking eye contact. "I'm supposed to be home before midnight."

"Oh, yeah. I'll take you home," he smiles.

We drive back home in silence, until Chase puts my favourite song on.

"I love this song!" I say, excited.

"Wow, she's beautiful and she has good taste in music," he chuckles and I feel a bit uneasy. I find it odd that we have so much in common.

Here I go again, self sabotaging. A great guy comes along and what do I do? Act suspicious of him.

"Thanks for tonight, Chase," I smile as we pull up to my house, feeling guilty for being so suspicious of him. He genuinely seems like a really sweet person. "I had a great time."

"Me too, Kat," he kisses me on the cheek and drives away.

As I walk to the door, I hear loud music and voices coming from inside. "What's with all the noise?" I ask Wyatt as I enter.

"I have a couple of friends over," he says casually.

And then I hear a familiar voice. "Hey man, you got any more beers?" asks the voice. My heart skips a beat. It's him. Will Walker. I look behind Wyatt to see him standing there, looking just as surprised as I am.

"Will Walker," I eye him playfully.

"Kathryn Davis," he mimics me, gazing into my eyes just like Chase had earlier. Only this time, I don't want to look away.

We stand there, staring at each other, until Wyatt interrupts, sounding confused, "Uh, you guys know each other?" I can see the narrowing of his eyes in the dim light of the hallway.

"Sorta," I say, finally looking away from Will.

"Right. How was the big date, anyway?" Wyatt asks.

"Fun. Chase is great," I say, shooting a glare at Will. He rolls his eyes, and I know that he knows what I'm thinking.

"McKnight? Really? I told you, you can do so much better," Will speaks, his voice slightly slurred.

"Guess I don't really care about what you have to say," I reply with a smirk, even though it isn't entirely true.

"Oh?" Will looks at me questioningly.

"Yeah," I say, trying to sound confident.

"Whatever," he winks as he walks out of my house.

"What about the beer?" I question.

"Got some at home," he replies, making me feel even more confused.

"I'll take that," I say, grabbing the beer from Wyatt's hand and walking into the living room.

"Hey Andy," I say to my brother's best friend, who is sprawled on the couch with a tub of popcorn in his hands. I notice that he has one of the roses that Chase got me tucked behind his ear. "Loving the new look."

"Thanks," he speaks with his mouth full of popcorn. "Sorry I stole your flower."

"Real attractive," I say, rolling my eyes, even though I can't help but think he really does look a bit hot, if you ignore the gross popcorn mouth.

"Your cousin is kinda weird, bro," Wyatt says to Andy.

"Oh, come on, Will's chill," Andy responds.

"Will Walker is your cousin?" I ask Andy and he just nods, stuffing the little bit of popcorn that is remaining into his mouth.

"Jeez Andy," Wyatt shakes his head, taking the tub from him and going to the kitchen to refill it.

"Hot," Andy sighs.

"What?" I narrow my eyes at him.

"It's hot tonight," he states.

"Oh wow, and here I am thinking you're talking about me." I say with a wink.

"You wish, Little Davis." he chuckles. I kinda do. But also not really. Andy is extremely attractive and I enjoy casually flirting with him but we can never ever be together. Like ever. Sure, he's cute. But that's all he is. My brother's hot friend. Sometimes even my friend.

I go to my room and change into my pyjamas, climbing into bed, hoping to have sweet Will dreams. Wait, did I say Will? I totally meant Chase.

.

.

.

A/N
What do you all think about Chase? And Andy? Do you like them?

I think Chris Wood makes a cool Andy. I looove him as Kai in The Vampire diaries. Don't worry, Andy isn't a psycho like Kai ;)

Anyway, thanks for reading!
Please vote and comment! xx