(Y/n)'s POV

~1 year later (Sorry for the massive timeskip)~

Gray and I had been dating for a year now. I just woke up in my dorm. I went to the bathroom to change and brush my teeth and hair. Levy left a note saying that she had gone to the library to study for an upcoming test.

Lucy was still sleeping. I had gotten closer to everyone within the past year. I got a black marker and drew a moustache, an eyepatch and a scar on Lucy's face. She woke up a few minutes later.

"Good morning (Y/n)."
"Good morning."

I managed to hold in my laugh. She went to the bathroom and screamed. I laughed my head off. She came back out, fuming.

"(Y/n)!"
"What?"
"How could you do this to my face?!"
"Are looks the only thing you care about?"
"N-no." *knock knock* I opened the door. It was Gray.
"Hey." He kissed my cheek.
"What's up with Lucy's face?"
"Nothing-"
"She drew on it while I was sleeping!"
"You should probably go wash it off before it gets completely dry."
"But it is completely dry!" I shrugged. She went into the bathroom.
"Sorry Lucy!" I called out to her.
"Come on, let's go."

I went with Gray to the school garden. Something had seemed off with him for the past half year. But I couldn't figure out what. We sat down under a cherry blossom tree.

"Gray, there's been something on your mind. Please tell me what it is."
"*sigh* I'm sorry (Y/n)."
"What do you mean? You didn't do anything wrong."
"I'm sorry (Y/n). I...I don't love you anymore. I've been dating Juvia for the past half year. I have loved her ever since then and...s-she told me that you have been dating Hibiki..."
"What?! So I get betrayed again?! You really believe what she told you?! I'm not seeing anyone except for you. She tried to hurt me because she was jealous of me and you believe her?!" Tears were flowing down my face.
"(Y/n)..."
"You believe her...over me?" He looked away.
"Fine, if that's how you want it. I'm gonna leave you with her." I walked off. My heart broke into a thousand pieces. Miyu saw me and ran up to me.
"What happened, (Y/n)-nee?"
"Gray...he broke up with me... He loved Juvia." She had a look of anger on her face.
"I'm gonna kill that bastard!" And with that, she stormed off. There was no way to stop her once she was angry.

Miyu's POV

I went to where Gray was. He was cuddling Juvia under a cherry blossom tree. How could he?!

"Oh, hey Miyu," he said casually.
"How could you be like this?! Just casually dating Juvia behind my sister's back!"
"Whoa, Miyu, calm down. First of all, she was the one dating Hibiki behind my back and I realised I love Juvia."
"She was not dating Hibiki behind your back! Juvia was the one that lied to get to you! Can't you see that?!"
"Has (Y/n) managed to get you to believe her over me/Juvia?"
"I would never believe her, she tried to hurt me!"
"That's in the past now. All (Y/n) did was pretend to love and stab me in the back. I will only love Juvia and I always have-"
"You were the one that stabbed her in her heart! Haven't you thought about her?!"
"Stop insulting my Gray-sama!" Juvia demanded and pushed me over.

I tried to get up but she kicked me back down. Gray just stood there, staring casually. Juvia kicked me more. Natsu came running this way and literally punched Juvia.

"Get away from her, you backstabbing bastards!" Natsu shouted.

(Y/n)'s POV

I had told Lucy everything. We then heard Natsu's voice and ran to where he was. Miyu was on the ground, bruised all over. Natsu was standing protectively in front of her. Juvia looked like the suspect. I ran up to Miyu and hugged her. She began crying. I glared at Juvia.

"Lucy, take care of Miyu."
"Okay." She ran to Miyu.
"Juvia!"

I took out the dagger that the bad guys that given me. I didn't care if I went to jail. I would not forgive anyone that hurt my family! Juvia looked at me in fear. I slashed her arm. Tears filled her eyes but I didn't care.

Gray got the dagger and kicked my stomach with really powerful strength. He was about to stab me but Mystogan grabbed his arm.

"Don't. You. Dare. Hurt. Her. Again," he said in a dangerous tone.
"Whatever."

Gray dropped the dagger and picked Juvia up and went away. Natsu had taken Miyu back inside. Lucy went with him. I coughed up blood.

"(Y/n)!" Mystogan ran to my side. He picked me up and took me to the infirmary. I wanted to go to sleep for some reason.
"No (Y/n)! Don't close your eyes."
"I'm trying not to..." Mira was inside and immediately ran to the bed Mystogan put me on when she saw the blood.
"What happened to you?!"
"Gray did it, he hurt her physically and emotionally." Mystogan told her everything.

~A few days later~

I was healing and much better than before, physically. But I still couldn't get over the fact that Gray had dumped me for Juvia. I still loved him, I just couldn't live with the fact that he hurt me and didn't protect my sister. So I cut myself everyday to make sure I was still living. Lots of people tried to stop me but couldn't. The principal came in.

"(Y/n), I need to talk to you."
"Can we talk here?"
"Yeah sure. I'm giving you time off school. Have a holiday and forget about Gray."
"Really?" He nodded. I laughed.
"Is this a joke?" Yeah, I had gone a bit insane. I cut myself more.
"Stop!"

His tone was frightening. In the end, I listened to what he said and went on a holiday. Who knows? I might never come back, I've already said goodbye to everyone except for Juvia and Gray. I would miss everyone...

Gray's POV

"Hey, where's (Y/n)? I haven't seen her around lately. Don't tell me she's still trying to get over the fact that I love Juvia," I asked Natsu.
"And why do you care?"
"I was just curious."
"Curiosity killed the cat."
"But satisfaction brought it back," I replied. He glared at me. Why did everyone believe (Y/n) over Juvia?
"She's gone on a holiday, probably never coming back," Natsu said then left me alone. That was when it hit me, I loved (Y/n) more than anything.

~Some time later~

"Juvia! Are you really telling the truth?"
"Of course not. I only wanted Gray-sama to be mine." I slapped her.
"G-Gray-sama?"
"Don't come crawling back to me."

I left with tears flowing down my face. How could I forgive myself for all the things I did to you?! (Y/n), I'm gonna find you no matter what.