Previously
He was the perfect person for (Y/N), unfortunately, not everyone thinks so.

And now...
Art class was over, you and AJ walked out of the class chatting animatedly, with Micheal trailing behind. "So (Y/N), do I have the pleasure of eating lunch with thou?" AJ asked with a wink. You punched his arm lightly. "Of course! Why wouldn't I? Tyler and Jackson are gonna be there too, I found out they have the same lunch as we do!" You announced grinning. You watched AJ's grin falter slightly when you mentioned the other boy's names but it was so fast you think it's just your imagination. "That's... great (Y/N)!" AJ said, wearing his signature goofy grin. "May I eat lunch with you and your... friends (Y/N)?" Micheal asked in a low voice behind you and AJ. There it is again... You heard a little growl escape from AJ, and when you saw his face you noticed he was frowning at Micheal. Micheal was glaring back at AJ and you heard a little growl leave him too. "What is it with you guys and growling? Come on let's go! We're gonna be late for class." 

As you were outside your class you bid goodbye to Micheal. You and AJ walked in and received lots of funny glances. He gripped your hand and led you to the back of the class, you were blushing furiously, not only from him grabbing your hand but from the class looking at you. "Hey AJ! (Y/N)!" You saw Jackson and Tyler waving their arms like mad signaling for you two to come over. "AJ let's go!" AJ was still holding your hand as he followed behind you. "When did you two get so close?" Tyler said with a smile but it didn't go to his eyes. He and Jackson were looking at AJ with jealousy as he released your hand. "We've always been close genius," AJ said giving Tyler a light punch in the arm. "What class is this?" Jackson asked as he played with the stone heart again. "Um..." No one else seemed to know the class you guys were in and everyone laughed at their stupidity.

~~ Time Skip Brought to you by Grammarly! My editor. ~~

Class ended and you finally figured out you were in science! Everyone was still laughing their asses off about not figuring it out from all the posters and beakers. You headed down to the auditorium, you always ate lunch outside it because it had the most shade and you knew tons of people there. AJ was standing directly next to you on your right, he was looking around and at the other boys as if to make sure they didn't do anything to you. Tyler and Jackson were goofing around with each other while Jackson was on your direct left. You walked to the outside of the auditorium and there you saw Micheal. He flashed a short small smile and waved at you. He frowned and glared at the other boys through his hair and you wondered why it seemed they all hated each other. "Micheal! AJ! Tyler! Jackson! To me now!" You yelled as you sat down on the wall. The four boys immediately walked up to you and gave you questioning glances. "Ok, why do you all hate each other?"

Micheal's POV

"Ok, why do you all hate each other?" (Y/N) asked. I don't hate them, I just don't like them being near you (Y/N). Can't you see that? I noticed the other boys glancing at each other looking surprised so I tried to do the same. I don't think it came across the way I wanted it to... When I looked at AJ he glared at me. "We don't hate each other!" AJ announced, and for some reason, I don' think that applied to me.

Tyler's POV

"Ok, why do you all hate each other?" (Y/N) asked. In my head, I let out a little laugh. I don't hate them, I could never hate them! They're like my brothers. But they want you, just like I do and I couldn't bear to see you with someone else, so when they get all cozy, I get upset. I love you, can't you see? I shared confused glances with AJ and Jackson, but Micheal looked like he was glaring at me. I turned away very fast. "We don't hate each other!" I heard AJ respond.

Jackson's POV

"Ok, why do you all hate each other?" (Y/N) asked. I looked at her with my signature puppy dog eyes. I could never hate anyone, especially them. Well, maybe except for Micheal... he's scary... I grew up with them, I've known them my whole life. I couldn't hate them, maybe dislike them because they want you (Y/N), but never hate. I exchanged questioning glances with everyone. Micheal was glaring at me. I squeaked and hid behind Tyler. "We don't hate each other!" AJ said surprised.

AJ's POV

"Ok, why do you all hate each other?" (Y/N) asked. I snickered a little. We don't hate each other, well... maybe except for Micheal, I think he has some issues. (AJ!!!!!!) But the rest of us most definitely do not hate each other. We're like family and I treat them like one. I just don't like it when they get near you. We've known each other since we were little and I know more about you (Y/N) than even you know. Oh, how I wish you could see that in all the hints I give. We all exchanged confused and questioning glances. My eyes landed on Micheal and it looked like he was glaring at me. I glared right back before turning to (Y/N). "We don't hate each other!" I said heroicly. 

2nd Person POV

You looked at each of them and studied their faces for the slightest trace of dishonesty. You didn't get any. "Fine. I believe you, for now." You said waving a finger in their faces. "FIRST ONE TO GET ME A COOKIE GETS A HUG!!" You yelled excitedly. You watched all the boys drop their bags and race to the cafeteria. You laughed. "MAKE SURE IT'S CHOCOLATE CHIP!" You yelled.

(A/N) soooooo reader~sama, what do you think of the story so far? All the boys scrambling to get you some cookies. Boy you must be happy... ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°  )