Hannah’s POV~

Charlie shook her head. “No I’m sorry I don’t” She said. “Wait, if Jill was killed because she blamed herself for someones death, what if that is why Steven was killed and not his daughter Lily” I said. “Well I guess we have another mirror to check” Sarah said. We left Charlie’s house and drove to Donna’s. Charlie followed in her car since there was no room in the Impala with all of us in it. When we arrived at the house the two brothers and Charlie went in. “So, a ghost tried to kill you?” I asked her. “Yeah, but we killed her before she killed me” Sarah said. “Why did she try to kill you?” I asked her. “Well, she was jealous because I took 'her' Cameron away from her. I heard her say it with my own ears." Sarah told me. “Well that must have sucked” I said to her. “Yeah it really did” Sarah said. We both started to laugh.

The boys came back out amid our laughing. “Well what has you two so excited” Dean asked us. “It’s nothing” I told him. “Well come on then, we need to do some research on Mary. There may be some sort of reason as to why she only kills here and nowhere else” Dean said. We got into the Impala and drove back to the library. “Everyone take a computer, look for anything that has to do with any sort of Mary that has died here” Dean said. I grabbed one of them and did some reasearch. I searched for anyone with the name of Mary that has died in Ohio. I found nothing. We were all looking for a few hours. “Guys look at this” Dean said. We all went over. “I searched for anyone in America with the name Mary who died in front of a mirror and I found this” Dean said. “Mary was 19 when someone broke into her apartment, murdered her, and cut out her eyes with a knife. Before she died in front of a large mirror, she tried to spell out her killer's name but only managed the letters T-R-E” Dean told us.. “So you think this Mary is the one in the legends?” Sarah asked “Yeah, so I guess that means we are going to Indiana” Dean said.

We followed Dean out to the car again. It only took us a few hours to get to Indiana. When we arrived we found the police station. We walked in. “Hello, we are looking for the detective that worked on the Mary Worthington case” Dean said. “That would be me” A man said stepping out from around the corner. “May we ask you a few questions?” I asked him. “Sure, follow me” The man said. We followed him into a back office. “What would you like to know?” He asked us. “Well first off, we would like to know exactly how she died” Sam said. “Well she was found in front of her mirror, her eyes had been surgically cut out and she, in her last moments before her death, she tried to write out the name of her attacker but she died before she could finish. She had written out T-R-E. Now, there was a surgeon in Indiana, his name was Trevor. From the beginning I was sure he was the one who had killed her. I thought that maybe she was having an affair with this man, but she couldn’t take it, threatened to tell his wife about it, so he broke in and killed her, but I could never prove it so he went uncharged and the case went cold” The man said. “Where is Mary buried?” Dean asked him. “She wasn’t buried, she was cremated” He told us. “What about this mirror? Where is that?” I asked. “After the case went cold it was sent back to her family” The man told us. “Where is the address?” Dean asked him. He wrote it on a piece of paper and gave it to Dean.

We walked back out to the car and we found the house. When we got there we found out he had sold it. On the bright side, he sold it to a store in Toledo. As we were leaving Sam’s phone starting ringing. He answered it. “Hello. Charlie! What’s wrong? Okay, calm down and tell me what happened” Sam said. There was silence while, I assume, Charlie told him what happened. “Okay, we will be there as soon as we can” Sam told her and hung up. “What’s wrong?” Sarah asked him. “Donna said ‘you know what’ in the mirror at the school bathroom, she is after Charlie now” Sam said. “Charlie!? What did Charlie do?” I asked. “Charlie blames herself for her boyfriend’s death, he killed himself but she blames herself for it” Dean said. He hit the gas and we were there in a little over an hour and a half. We found Charlie in her room, curled up on her bed. The boys covered everything reflective in her room. “Charlie, it’s okay, you can look now” Dean said. “Wait, my glasses” I said. I pulled them off and nudged Sarah and she did the same. “I can’t stay like this forever” Charlie said. “Am I going to die?” She asked. “No Charlie, we won’t let that happen. We are going to stop this right now, but you must promise not to look at anything that is reflective. We will call you when it is safe to look” Dean said. She nodded and we left her.