Aries - Lily

Taurus - Jeff the Killer

Gemini - Lazari

Cancer - Smile Dog

Leo - Sally

Virgo - Ticci Toby

Libra - Nina the Killer

Scorpio - Jason the Toymaker

Sagittarius - Slenderman

Capricorn - Eyeless Jack

Aquarius - Grinny Cat

Pisces - Jane the Killer