Finally got this up again thanks to a request from Sopo2020

Aries: Nurse Ann

Taurus: Zalgo (O-o Oof. I guess you're well protected.)

Gemini: Splendorman

Cancer: Jason the Toymaker

Leo: Nina the Killer

Virgo: Jeff the Killer

Libra: Slenderman

Scorpio: Eyeless Jack

Sagittarius: Lazari

Capricorn: Trenderman

Aquarius: Dr. Smiley

Pisces: Clockwork