I think someone requested this.

Aries: Eyeless Jack

Taurus: Laughing Jack

Gemini: Bloody Painter

Cancer: Jason the Toymaker

Leo: Candypop

Virgo: Jeffrey the Killer (I had to.)

Libra: Slenderman (oh no... you're grounded)

Scorpio: Masky

Sagittarius: The Puppeteer

Capricorn: Dark Link

Aquarius: BEN Drowned

Pisces: Dr. Smiley (you should've eaten your apple.)