1.) You were (name) the (cp nickname), You were a well known killer, not because of the killing but because of the messages you would leave behind after murdering the person.
You're on the wanted list, not just for the cops but the creepypasta.

You had caught slenderman, the boss of the creepypasta, attention.
He decided to send (crush) to track you down and bring you to the slender mansion, to join in working for Slenderman.

Which brings you here,
You were just walking through the woods, just wanted to relax a bit however you soon frozed when you heard someone stepping on something. You looked around wary "Who's there!? Show yourself!" You yelled out.
You waited for a moment until someone stepped out of hiding, you look up and down at them, they had (how your crush looks).

They spoke "Look. Let's make this easy, come with me  and there won't be any problems."

What do you do?

2.) You were a new member of creepypasta, slenderman had found you hurt from (Whatever injuries you had).
He took you to the slender mansion and treated your wounds, after that, he introduced you to everyone who lived in the mansion.
That's when you met (crush)

3.) (This is before you and the others become a killer/monster or just a human)

You had just moved in (Whatever neighborhood), as you were settling in your new home, you heard knocking from your front door.

You answer the door, you saw a (man/woman).
They looked at you, smiling slightly "Hey, I'm (crush). I want to be the first one to say, Welcome to the neighborhood!" They said

You...?

4.) Switch it

5.) Make it up