Slenderman

You never caught him singing. All of his conversations were telepathic, since he had no mouth. He never sang. Ever.

Jeff the Killer

You were making sandwiches when you thought you heard singing. Curious, you grabbed your phone, went to the camera, and hit record. You were very glad you did. You started by investigating your room. You cracked the door open just a bit, and Jeff's voice flooded through the house. It was really hard not to burst out laughing.

"Don't you ever say I'm not real or gay, cause I'll always hunt you. Chasing with a knife, you run for your life, only I can stop you. I came in and I staaaaaabed your balls! I also slit your throaaaat and arms! All I wanted was to breaaak your neck! All I ever did was say Go to sleep!"

Needless to say, you never deleted that video. He never found out about it.

Eyeless Jack

You were trying to sleep, when you heard your window creak open. Knowing who it was, you ignored it. It must've looked like you were really sleeping, because EJ didn't say anything at all. About half an hour passed, and you thought he had left. You were about to get up to get something to drink when a soft voice sang a soothing melody. "It's getting late and I cannot seem to find my way home tonight. It feels like I am falling down a rabbit hole. Falling for forever, wonderfully wandering alone."

You listened to the whole song, mesmerised by his voice. When he finished, you sat up, and he looked at you, surprised. You just grinned and hugged him.

Masky

You were walking in the woods, planning on surprising Masky, when a voice filled the silence of the woods. "It's my life and it's now or never Cuz I ain't gonna live forever! I just wanna live while I'm alive! My heart is like an open highway! Like Frankie said, I did it my way! I just wanna live while I'm alive. It's! My! Life!"

After pinpointing where the voice was coming from, you walked in that direction to find none other than Masky, his back turned to you. With an evil grin on your face, you made your presence known. "What a lovely voice," you said happily, watching him jump, and spin around with a knife in hand. "I wonder who that was that was singing," you teased as he relaxed at the sight of you.

"Shut up, (Y/N)."

Hoodie

Apparently, Hoodie doesn't stutter when he's singing. It's like he's a whole different person.

You two were happily walking in the park, and you had excused yourself to get some ice cream from a truck passing by. On your way back, you saw that he had put earbuds in, and he was singing aloud, oblivious to you. Curious, you approached him to hear what he was singing, surprised to hear him stutter-free.

"You don't know shit shit shit, don't know a goddamn thing about me!" he was singing. "Keep looking down on me, I am more than you'll ever be. Cut me deep, but I won't bleed. You're gonna kick, kick, kick me when I'm down! By all means, put me through hell, and I'll make you see. I'll be your worst enemy! Try to kick, kick, kick me when I'm down!"

Wow, you thought to yourself. You hadn't thought of Hoodie as the type to listen to that kind of music. Guess you can't judge a book by its cover.

Ticci Toby

Toby was spending the night, but he had to take a shower, given he had just arrived from a kill. Yay. How fun. Anyways, he was in the shower, washing off all the blood, while you were washing his clothes for him, since you're just nice like that.

You were coming out from the laundry room, and that's when you heard it. His voice, without the cute little stutter that you adore. It reminded you of how people with accents suddenly seem to drop their accents when they sing. "Some legends are told. Some turn to dust or to gold. But you will remember me. Remember me for centuries!" he sang.

About five minutes later, he came into the room with a towel wrapped around his waist. You blushed a bit, and told him that he'd have to wear your brother's clothes while he waited on the laundry.

BEN Drowned

As always, you two were playing video games. You were listening to Pandora as you played, and as a song ended, you paused the game to make lunch. After preparing sandwiches for yourself, you entered the living room to an interesting sight. BEN was standing on the couch, facing away from you, while singing along to the current song that was playing.

"Mortal kings are ruling castles! Welcome to my world of fun! Liars settle into sockets, flip the switch and watch them run! Oh yeeeeeeeaaaaaaaah! Taking back back taking back back the crown! I'm all dressed up and naked! I see what's mine and take it! Oh yeah! The crown! So close I can taste it! I see what's mine and take it!"

You grinned at the sight and gave a fake cough to make yourself known. BEN turned around and, immediately, his face turned a very deep shade of red. "H-how much of that did you see?" he asked.

"Enough," you said in answer, sitting down and unpausing the game as if nothing had happened.

~~

Heyo! So what do you think of the latest chapter? After he caught you singing, I thought it would only be fair if you caught him. Minus Slendy. He legit will not sing. It's short, but it's something. So I hope you liked it, and if you have anything to say, feel free to comment. I guess that's it for now.

~MishaIsOurOverlord1