I finally managed to narrow down these winners!

Honorable mentions: 

getoveryourself

I love the snowflake twist you added, though I feel like bigger blood drop could be better blended with the crown. Otherwise, this is beautiful! 

shotsandsquats

sometimes, simple covers are the best- I love how you went out of the box with the prompt!

winners, please PM winterinheaven for a five honest comments on any of your books

Third place: 

liligrace

I think the overall concept is great- though I think that the text could be more solid and you could've had a textured background. Perhaps even play with brightness and coloring to make the flames pop?

please PM -verdant- for your custom graphic. 

Second place:

cupofno

This cover is absolutely beautiful. The only adjustment you might want to make is to play about with the brightness. Otherwise, the colors of this graphic would appear to look dull.

please PM -TheAnimeFreak- for a custom character drawing

First place:

sheliaroug17

I LOVE THIS! Your graphic was the closest example of what I had in mind when I thought of this contest and I love the details!  However, maybe duplicate your text layers for the "H" and "I" because the swirls look a bit too thin.

disporum

While the other winner's entry was sharp, I absolutely love the warm touch of this cover. All the colors blend in with each other and this is just absolutely enchanting. 

winners please PM -vellichor for her  resources pack and a custom banner!