Dipper had his eyes clenched shut. Wait. He opened his eyes to look at the pirate staring down at him. His eyes were still filled with hatred but there was something up. There was no way that he had missed from that close. He should have been shot on the spot.

He had spared him.

Dipper got up crawling to the ocean slowly. He needed water desperately.

Dipper managed to get halfway before he felt himself being hoisted up on a shoulder.

"Let me go!" Dipper struggled, but not too much, he could feel his body draining of energy.

The man didn't even pay attention to his pleas and brought him to his ship.

"STOP! LET ME GO! I DEMAND THAT YOU LET ME GO! I'LL KILL YOU!" Dipper was thrown into a tub filled with water. He felt his legs merge and turn into a bright blue tail.

"Like I thought." The man muttered under his breath.

Dipper closed his eyes refusing to look at him. He couldn't. He knew that he would never be able to go back to the ocean again. He had broken the number 1 rule in the siren handbook.

Never Let A Human See Your Tail.

"What are you going to do to me?" Dipper asked finally accepting his fate.

"Well, first we gotta get that bullet out of your shoulder." The man said in a hushed voice. He then looks at the siren squinting. "Or I could just kill you for killing one of my men." He pulled a small dagger of a small sheath on his belt and held it up to his neck. "An eye for an eye is it not?"

Dipper looked down holding his tongue. He shouldn't have gone.

"And on top of that, you threatened to kill me." The tall blonde pressed the blade against Dipper's neck and Dipper almost jerked at the feel but restrained himself. "How do you plead?"

The brown haired siren bit his tongue. What was he supposed to say to that? How was he going to get out of this? Dipper felt the tears make their way down his face, setting the trail for the next ones. He looked down once again avoiding his stares. He could still feel them.

The man put his dagger back into his sheath and grabbed the siren by his hair yanking his head upwards, making him flinch in return.

"I asked you a question!" He yelled to the smaller. His expression was terrifying, and Dipper swore he saw the human's eyes flash bright red, from their normal blue colour.

"I-I'm sorry!" He said in a flurry of emotions. As he sat in the bath his shoulder bled out, turning the water a bright red. He put his hand on the wound as if he was trying to hide it.

The man lets go of Dipper's hair practically throwing him back. He got up from his position and walked out of the room. Leaving Dipper alone with his thoughts.

Dipper's head was submerged in the water. He had been like that for about five hours now and personally, he felt better that way. He was just glad that the tub was large enough for his whole body to be submerged.

He felt the sway of the boat as he thought about particularly nothing. They had been sailing for awhile now. Honestly, Dipper was afraid of what Bill might do to him. That was his name. Or at least that's what he had told Dipper. However the siren refused to let his name pass his lips, so Bill called him Pinetree instead. Because of the blue pine tree that was imprinted in his arm with a bright colour of blue.

Dipper sighed watching as the air bubbles rise to the top. He felt the bandage that was taped to his shoulder. It still hurt. Why didn't Bill kill him?

Dipper heard the door opening and his head shot straight up and he looked at Bill.

"Is your arm ok?" Bill asked but got no answer.

Finally, Dipper realized he was asked something and quickly answered with a firm 'yes'.

Dipper had become more timid in the five hours that he had been captured. And Bill knew this very well.

Bill reached out grabbing some of Dipper's hair, earning a flinch in return. Bill looked at him before saying sorry and heading out of the bathroom leaving Dipper alone to his thoughts once again.

Wait did he- Dipper watched as the tall blonde left him.

God, why didn't he just follow the rule that time?  

~*~*~*~

Sorry that this is a little short. Anyway here it is! I'll make sure to write more as soon as I can.

*sips tea*

~Orderly nightmare