"BEN!"

You marched into his room, scaring him to death. "Wha-what do you want, (Y/N)?!"he asked you, trembling. BEN had been playing video games, as usual. You smirked and walked up to his face, causing him to blush slightly. "Me. You. Cookies. NOW."you said to the elf. BEN, now recovered from your outburst into his room, scratched the back of his head. "Er, cookies?" You nodded.

BEN looked confused. There was an awkward silence until you spoke up. "What I MEANT was it's Sally's birthday tomorrow, and she wants cookies instead of cake..." you said. BEN still looked confused as ever.

"Cookies instead of cake? Really?" he asked. "Y-yeah..." you said.

Suddenly, you grabbed his arm without thinking, and dragged him downstairs, muttering something about "how it wasn't your fault you had to do this" and "it was Slendy's idea"

Once you got downstairs, you immediately got out the ingredients. BEN stood off to the side, watching, keeping his perverted thoughts to himself. When you got everything out, you walked over to him. "BEN? Earth to BEN~" you said, waving a hand in his face. He snapped out of his daze. "S-sorry, (Y/N)..."

You gave him a smile before walking off, grabbing all of the ingredients for the cookies, and plopping them on the counter. "We're making sugar cookies." you said to him. He nodded. You stood there a moment, staring into his red orbs, until he gave you a questioning look.

"(Y/N)?"

Your face was now completely red. "Oh, uhm, sorry." you stuttered. BEN smirked. "Well, let's get started then."

As he went through all the ingredients, getting the bowls, spoons, and all that jazz out, you were thinking. Why did you blush? Better yet, why were you staring into his eyes like he was some prince? Maybe you actually-

NO! You shook off your thoughts. He was a killer, how could...

"Um, (Y/N)? You alright?" BEN asked, a concerned tone in his voice. You gave him a smile. "Y-yeah, just fine. Let's make these cookies, heh..." you said smiling. BEN handed you some ingredients. "Now, I think that you first put in the water..."

Ding!

You and BEN looked at each other excitedly. Finally!

"Those cookies took so long!" He complained, waving his arms in the air. You lightly chuckled. "I know, right! At least they're done..." you said.

You opened the oven and took them out. They looked ok, considering BEN Drowned helped you make them. You turned around and saw him eagerly standing there.

BEN came towards you grinning. "(Y/N), I wanna eat them now!" he pouted. You giggled. "Sorry, but these are for tomorrow."

~Time skip to the next day~

You woke up. "Ugh, what time is it?" you grumbled. 2:48. You sighed leaning back.

Clank.

A noise sounded from the kitchen. Curiosity got the better of you, and you went downstairs.

The fridge light was on.

You walked into the kitchen. "BEN?!" you asked. He froze. "Um, what are you doing?" He was obviously looking for the...cookies? You looked to the plate in his hand.

"Heh, oh hi, (Y/N)..." BEN said, blushing. You rolled your eyes. "Tomorrow." You remembered how tired you were, and yawned. "I'm going to bed now...." He nodded.

You walked up to him, and kissed him on the the cheek.

"Night, BEN." you said, walking away, leaving a very surprised BEN standing there.