Okay, so the first thing I want you to know is that I'm just telling my opinions and what I think of this, and if you have different opinions from mine that's perfectly okay and if you do want to say it, you can do that but don't say it too rudely as I don't mean to offend anyone.

 She glanced at Leo, fixed her eyes on Jason like he might be worthy of her attention, then curled her lip at Piper as if she were a week-old burrito that had just been pulled out of a Dumpster. Piper knew this girl's type. She'd dealt with a lot of girls like this at Wilderness School and every other stupid school her father had sent her to. Piper knew instantly they were going to be enemies.

First of all, I know that this could have been the case. She could have just been observing how good they could be at fighting. Even though we know that wasn't what Drew meant, and Drew was wrong to size them up by their looks, Piper shouldn't have assumed she would hate Drew right after just seeing her look up Jason and Leo.

We know that Leo as scrawny wouldn't look like the greatest fighter (which is wrong he's absolutely great at stuff) and Jason would because of you know muscles and stuff. But deciding instantly they were going to be enemies, well that is plain rude. Like why the fuck would you decide that a random person you knew for one second was going to be an enemy. ENEMY  out of all things. It could have been bully but nooooo drew has to be Piper's mortal enemy.

Well,‖ the girl said, ―I hope they're worth the trouble

That was rude. Drew is entitled to not liking demigods but she doesn't have to voice it out loud. She should have enough sense to know that you don't just wonder if a person is worth the trouble from DYING. No one should just be killed because they aren't worth it.

Piper stepped forward, ready to smack her

Okay, so piper wouldn't hurt the girls at wilderness school at commenting on her mum or dad but she would do that for herself, and besides if she thinks it that way then she shouldn't have even chopped off her own hair with plastic scissors. Like WHY?? If you'll be angry someone gives their honest opinion and you don't like it either then why would you do it?? That makes it sound like you wanted to fit into some group and a random person said you looked horrible like that and you didn't like it either and you SMACK HER??? 

LIKE WHY WAS THE SMACKING PART INCLUDED???? it's not good to hurt anyone and it's a good thing that Annabeth stopped her. Drew might be vain and not like to fight but I'm sure Chiron would make sure everyone would be trained. HE LIKES TO MAKE SURE THEY DON'T DIE. It removes the point of surviving.

AND DREW LITERALLY RETURNS HOME INSTEAD OF AS AN YEAR-ROUND CAMPER. Now that doesn't make sense. Shouldn't Drew know how to fight then, because she has to fight against monsters RIGHT???? even if her smell isn't much, some monsters will still come to hunt her right???? BUT SHE SURVIVED. SHE DIDN'T DIE. UNLIKE SOOOOO many campers before HER!!!

Could you flunk out of monster fighting?

Piper DID NOT want to fight monsters. She didn't want to get hurt like that and that does not mean that she sets out from the cabin. she still HAS TO DO IT. DREW HAD TO, LACY HAD TO, MITCHELL HAD TO, because Chiron wanted them to survive. AND THEY DID. Piper is not good at fighting as shown in the mark of Athena she just handed her knife to coach Hedge- leaving her defenceless. 

SHE KNEW SHE COULDN'T FIGHT WITH IT. She knew it would be better with Coach Hedge so that he could protect the others and himself. She would have learned to fight but this line clearly says that she IS NOT the perfect fighter who is really good at fighting. But somehow, she is super good at fighting in the blood of Olympus and that DOES NOT MAKE SENSE.

PIPER DIDN'T REMEMBER MUCH ABOUT the rest of the night. They told their story and answered a million questions from the other campers, but finally, Chiron saw how tired they were and ordered them to bed.
It felt so good to sleep on a real mattress, and Piper was so exhausted, she crashed immediately, which spared her any worry about what it would be like returning to the Aphrodite cabin.
The next morning she woke in her bunk, feeling reinvigorated. The sun came through the windows along with a pleasant breeze. It might've been spring instead of winter. Birds sang. Monsters howled in the woods. Breakfast smells wafted from the dining pavilion—bacon, pancakes, and all sorts of wonderful things.
Drew and her gang were frowning down at her, their arms crossed.
―Morning.‖ Piper sat up and smiled. ―Beautiful day.‖
―You're going to make us late for breakfast,‖ Drew said, ―which means you get to clean the cabin for inspection.‖
A week ago, Piper would've either punched Drew in the face, or hidden back under her covers. Now she thought about the Cyclopes in Detroit, Medea in Chicago, Midas turning her to gold in Omaha. Looking at Drew, who used to bother her, Piper laughed.
Drew's smug expression crumbled. She backed up, then remembered she was supposed to be angry. ―What are you—‖
―Challenging you,‖ Piper said. ―How about noon in the arena? You can choose the weapons.‖
She got out of bed, stretched leisurely, and beamed at her cabinmates. She spotted Mitchell and Lacy, who'd helped her pack for the quest. They were smiling tentatively, their eyes flitting from Piper to Drew like this might be a very interesting tennis game.
―I missed you guys!‖ Piper announced. ―We're going to have a great time when I'm senior counsellor.‖
Drew turned bug juice red. Even her closest lieutenants looked a little nervous. This wasn't in their script.
―You—‖ Drew spluttered. ―You ugly little witch! I've been here the longest. You can't just—‖
―Challenge you?‖ Piper said. ―Sure, I can. Camp rules: I've been claimed by Aphrodite. I've completed a quest, which is one more than you‟ve completed. If I feel I can do a better job, I can challenge you. Unless you just want to step down. Did I get all that right, Mitchell?‖
―Just right, Piper.‖ Mitchell was grinning. Lacy was bouncing up and down like she was trying to achieve liftoff.
A few of the other kids started to grin as if they were enjoying the different colours Drew's face was turning.
"Step down?" Drew shrieked. ―You're crazy!‖
Piper shrugged. Then fast as a viper, she pulled Katoptris from under her pillow, unsheathed the dagger, and thrust the point under Drew's chin.

Okay, yeah that's fine. She must have planned it or practised it, even though I know it's not mentioned. But if she thought of it on the spot it doesn't make sense. IN THE WHOLE QUEST SHE BARELY FOUGHT WITH HER DAGGER. She just used her charm speak which I'll probs address in another chapter.

 Everybody else backed up fast. One guy crashed into a makeup table and sent up a plume of pink powder.

―A duel, then,‖ Piper said cheerfully. ―If you don't want to wait until noon, now is fine. You've turned this cabin into a dictatorship, Drew. Silena Beauregard knew better than that. Aphrodite is about love and beauty. Being loving. Spreading beauty. Good friends. Good times. Good deeds. Not just looking good. Silena made mistakes, but in the end, she stood by her friends. That's why she was a hero. I'm going to set things right, and I've got a feeling Mom will be on my side. Want to find out?‖

WHY?? Drew is the oldest daughter of Aphrodite. She is obviously the best fighter. She should be having powerful charm speak Piper is correct that Drew as teaching the wrong thing but still.

THERE IS NO WAY THAT PIPER- WHO BARELY KNEW SHE WAS A DEMIGOD FOR ONE WEEK CAN DEFEAT a demigod who has the SAME powers as her and has been training the MOST IN THE WHOLE CABIN. 

that does not make any sense at all. Piper- barely any skill with the dagger. and we know that females don't easily get charmed by charm speak and DREW IS A CHARM SPEAKER HERSELF. so how does Piper defeat drew???? HOW???? and why is DREW SCARED?? she has faced war, lost her sister, lost siblings, faced sooo many monsters and yet she is scared of one girl????

Drew went cross-eyed looking down the blade of Piper's dagger.
A second passed. Then two. Piper didn't care. She was absolutely happy and confident. It must've shown in her smile.
―I ... step down,‖ Drew grumbled. ―But if you think I'm ever going to forget this, McLean—‖
―Oh, I hope you won't,‖ Piper said. ―Now, run along to the dining pavilion, and explain to Chiron why we're late. There's been a change of leadership.‖
Drew backed to the door. Even her closest lieutenants didn't follow her. She was about to leave when Piper said, ―Oh, and Drew, honey?‖
The former counsellor looked back reluctantly.
―In case you think I'm not a true daughter of Aphrodite,‖ Piper said, ―don't even look at Jason Grace. He may not know it yet, but he's mine. If you even try to make a move, I will load you into a catapult and shoot you across Long Island Soun

THAT WAS A DEATH THREAT! how did you not notice???? if you did- congrats. AND SECOND OF ALL EVEN APHRODITE WOULD BE ANGRY IF PIPER THREATENED ONE OF HER DAUGHTERS- the oldest one, the one who knew Selena the best, to death. liKE WHY???

Piper threatened her own sister to death!!!! WOULD YOU DO THAT??? NO, YOU WON'T, until your sister is a criminal and you are the police but that is a different case. DID YOU NOT NOTICE WHAT IS THE TOPIC.

iT'S Jason.  A BOY. YOu won't threaten your sister to death over a boy, would you????  Piper was being over possessive. JASON WASN'T EVEN HER BOYFRIEND AT THAT TIME AND HE BARELY HAD MEMORIES!!! why would she go chasing after him then????? WHYYYYYY???? AND THEN THREATENING HER SISTER- that's one of the most annoying things. I don't have a good relationship with my sister (kind of like their's except for the killing part) and I would never threaten her- WITH DEATH OR SOMETHING OF THAT MEASURE.

Thanks for coming to my rant, and I hope that you don't take personal offence.