This was a truth/dare that somehow slipped from my list, but if the characters were to call their crush's by pet names for the rest of the game here's what the names would be:

Rich to Jake: "I'd call him my lil' DILL-inger PICKLE"

Michael to Jeremy: "JERBEAR, duh."

Jeremy to Michael: "Mikeypoo~"

Christine to Jenna: "...Jenny?"

Jenna to Christine: "Juliet two point WHOAH."

Brooke to Chloe: "Chlo Chlo <3"

Chloe to Brooke: *squeaking noises*