summary

In which a young Gryffindor girl catches the eye of the Marauders and they discover the secrets to Sarah's smile, or lack thereof.

Or

Sarah was found by an Auror, covered in blood, when she was five. She hasn't spoken a word since. Upon going to Hogwarts, the Marauders decide to take care of her, extremely intrigued by her lack of words. By her fifth year, Sarah stops smiling, so they get worried. It doesn't help their case when she becomes friends with Regulus Black, Sirius' younger, Slytherin brother.

Quotes

"McGonagall, what're we supposed to do? It's freaking us out. She doesn't even smile anymore."

"Sarah, you're very special to me. You know that. Would you tell me why you don't talk?"

"She's a mystery, that Sarah. Never told anyone what happened that night, now look where she is."

Cast List
Ben Barnes as Sirius Black
Aaron Taylor Johnson as James Potter
Andrew Garfield as Remus Lupin
Your Choice as Peter Pettigrew
Your Choice as Sarah
Your Choice as Regulus Black

Bucky's Comments
In a nutshell, an Auror found Sarah when she was really young, covered in blood and no one knows why. Only Sarah, who never said a word. At Hogwarts, the Marauders try and prank her, but she just smiles at them. They try to get her to talk, but she doesn't, so they decide to take care of her. She sees them as her older brothers. In her 4th year, she meets Regulus, but doesn't inform the boys. By fifth year, she gets really sad and stood smiling, which worries her boys. Ten they learn about Regulus and stuff happens after that. Kinda vague, but that's all I got. Please treat her kindly.

=D