Potential face claims for Benjy Fenwick:

NAME: Rami Malek
DATE OF BIRTH: 12 May 1981
NATIONALITY: American
EYE COLOR: green
HAIR COLOR: black

NAME: Sam Claflin
DATE OF BIRTH: 27 June 1986
NATIONALITY: English
EYE COLOR: green
HAIR COLOR: brown

NAME: Jean-Luc Bilodeau
DATE OF BIRTH: 4 November 1990
NATIONALITY: Canadian
EYE COLOR: dark brown
HAIR COLOR: light brown

NAME: Max Irons
DATE OF BIRTH: 17 October 1985
NATIONALITY: English
EYE COLOR: green
HAIR COLOR: light brown

NAME: Ross Butler
DATE OF BIRTH: 17 May 1990
NATIONALITY: Asian-American
EYE COLOR: brown
HAIR COLOR: black

NAME: Nico Mirallegro
DATE OF BIRTH: 26 January 1991
NATIONALITY: British
EYE COLOR: brown
HAIR COLOR: brown

NAME: Lucas Aurelien
DATE OF BIRTH: unknown
NATIONALITY: French
EYE COLOR: brown
HAIR COLOR: brown

NAME: Robert Sheehan
DATE OF BIRTH: 7 January 1988
NATIONALITY: Irish
EYE COLOR: green
HAIR COLOR: black

NAME: Tre Samuels
DATE OF BIRTH: 12 April 1999
NATIONALITY: Australian
EYE COLOR: brown
HAIR COLOR: brown

NAME: Logan Lerman
DATE OF BIRTH: 19 January 1992
NATIONALITY: American
EYE COLOR: blue
HAIR COLOR: black

NAME: James McAvoy
DATE OF BIRTH: 21 April 1979
NATIONALITY: Scottish
EYE COLOR: blue
HAIR COLOR: light brown

NAME: Evan Peters
DATE OF BIRTH: 20 January 1987
NATIONALITY: American
EYE COLOR: brown
HAIR COLOR: brown

(suggested by LeviosaDragon)