We have a WINNER!!! Drum roll, please...

...

Cover #2!!!
There was really no need to do a second vote, so I just counted this as the winner. Here are the final standings:

1st Place: Cover #2 (obviously)
2nd Place: Cover #1
3rd Place: Cover #4
4th Place: Cover #3

I'm actually surprised that cover #1 won. I mean, really surprised. My personal favorite is #1, but hey! I like all of them, but the best way to get more followers is to go by "the customer is always right" rule. Only with followers. You know what? Never mind. I'm making this really weird.