I'm probably gonna work on the story first if I get enough motivation to, but just know that the smallest of the characters is not a love interest, it is the protagonist's younger sister

Her name is we'll go from left to right (I want to dry and do a story with two very popular gay stereotypes, however these two ain't gay, the bad boy is straight while the love interest OwO cat is Pan)

The characters are as follows:
Ryan
Siara
Hayley
Jacob.

And if you're wondering what's with the wings on Siara & Hayley, those aren't wings, but they're hair clips.

Either way I want you guys to take a guess on which of the two boys our main character ends up choosing

Also fun fact, Ryan has Vitiligo while Hailey was just scratched by her pet cat.

Another thing about the two girls, it's that Siara is Haley's adopted sister, however Haley doesn't treat Siara any different because of that fact because she gives a damn about her sisters safety.