Gabriel arrived at Sam's house around 7:15. They were going to meet Adam, Samandriel and Kevin in the rich neighborhood where they always went trick or treating, since that neighborhood happened to have the best effects and the most candy.

Sam opened the door wearing a plaid shirt, black jeans and black eye contacts. He looked like a demon, though Gabriel supposed that was what he was going for.

Gabriel, true to what he had said before, was going as an archangel. The wings were large and gold, not to mention there were six of them. Gabriel was pretty damn proud. He was also wearing a tan toga-like piece of clothing and some brown sandals, which was a slightly bad idea, as it was generally quite chilly in October, especially in New York.

"So, I mention the word demon-hunter, but all you hear is demon?" Gabriel opened with, going back to his former costume suggestion.

"Eh," Sam waved his hand, "This was just easier."

"So easy means that you just happen to have black eye contacts laying around your house?"

"Yes."

"Ok then, shall we?" Gabriel offered his arm to Sam.

Sam laughed, "We shall."
~~~~~~

Sam and Gabriel met up with Adam, Samandriel and Kevin at the beginning of their route. There were so many houses (and so much candy) that by the time they were halfway through the neighborhood, the boy's pillowcases were full. Gabriel, having thought ahead, brought two extras, as he assumed that Sam wouldn't know how much candy there would be. Adam had also forgot to bring an extra, but he beamed brilliantly when Samandriel passed him another pillowcase after taking his first extra for himself.

"Oh come on, I thought I'd be at least marginally a third wheel cause who the hell isn't one with fucking Adamandriel in their faces, but with you two to back me up, but goddamn you guys, now I'm a fifth wheel?" Kevin said, making the four other boys blush and Kevin walk off shaking his head.

~~~~~~

A few minutes after Sam left to go trick or treating, Cas came over to Dean's house for their horror movie marathon. The two were in the Winchester's living room with popcorn, burgers, and a ton of candy that Cas had brought.

They were about to start Poltergeist, as they had chosen for the first movie of the night, when Mary Winchester came in and said, "You boys need anything? Some snacks? A con-"

"Mom, no. Just please, no," Dean interrupted her.

"Oh fine, just don't do anything I wouldn't do." She gave an exaggerated wink at Dean.

"What wouldn't you do?" Dean yelled as she exited.

Cas, not being able to hold in his laughter anymore, started giggling. "So, I take it that in your parent's relationship, your mom is the bad influence?"

"Yeah. Dad teases us and stuff, but he's still pretty strict about rules. Mom lets us do pretty much anything, as long as it's not too illegal."

Cas nodded, popping a Kit Kat into his mouth. "I like your mom. She's cool."

The main menu popped up on the DVD player, and Dean hit play.

"Oh, I forgot to ask, do you get scared easily?" Dean asked Cas.

"Not usually. Well, never is more like it, I guess. You?" Cas asked.

"I get scared sometimes, not that much though," Dean replied, and the two started watching the movie. (I have never watched Poltergeist before so you're not gonna hear anything about the movie.)

Aside from a few well assorted jump scares, the movie didn't scare Dean all that much. Truthfully, it scared Cas a lot less than it did Dean, but Dean will say otherwise until the end of time (must be some fragile masculinity thing that only shows up when he's trying to impress his crush with his manliness.) They would occasionally make offhanded comments to each other about certain scenes, "I don't care if this is a horror movie, they still coulda made it gayer," and talking about how dumb the characters were, "Honestly, just get some salt and a lighter and boom, you're done."

They were both laughing and joking so much throughout the movie that they didn't even notice that the credits started rolling. After they had decided on a second movie, Cas excused himself to go use the bathroom. Not even two seconds after Dean heard the bathroom door close, his dad was at the entrance to the living room.

"So, Cas is over again," John gave his son a knowing smile.

Dean groaned. "Are you and mom mind readers or something? How the hell do you know?" He whisper-yelled.

"The way you look at him is a dead giveaway; I used to look at your mom the same way."

"What way? The friend way? Cause that's all I'm seein'," Dean chuckled nervously.

Sending his son a face that said, 'I'm so done with your shit Dean, John replied, "Dean, are you serious? You are so in love with him it's literally sickening. Grow some balls and ask him ou-"

John was interrupted by the sound of the bathroom door opening. Hearing Cas's footsteps coming their way, Dean shot up, clamped a hand over his father's mouth and laughed, "Haha funny joke dad, now get out of my room!" Dean then shoved him out of the living room just as Cas got back.

"This is the family room, not your room!" John laughed as he left.

"Whatever!"

Cas entered the room and laid down on the couch next to Dean and they started marathoning Harry Potter from the beginning until they fell asleep.

~~~~~~

After the five traded their candy with each other in the street, Adam and Samandriel broke off to go over to Samandriel's house, Kevin's mom picked him up and Sam and Gabriel were left to walk back to their respective houses.

"Since they're doing the sleepover thing, wanna sleep over at my place?" Gabe asked Sam, popping a Tootsie Pop into his mouth.

"Sure, we just have to stop by my house so I can get a change of clothes and tell my parents where I'm gonna be."

"Okie dokie."

They stopped by Sam's house after a short walk. Gabriel was waiting in the kitchen talking with Mary, (who was somehow still awake despite it being 3 am) when Sam came bounding down the steps with a duffel bag over his shoulder and a shit-eating grin. He was practically bouncing with glee. Gabriel smiled at the sight but then curiosity overtook him and he asked, "Ok, what happened?"

Sam quietly motioned for his mom and Gabriel to follow him to the living room where Cas and Dean were sound asleep on the couch together with Prisoner of Azkaban playing in the background.

"Aww, how cute," Mary whispered, taking a picture of them.

"Now here's to hoping it gets them somewhere," Gabriel commented as they walked away, leaving the older boys in peace.

"Well, you boys have fun, don't eat too much candy!" Mary said, bidding Sam and Gabriel farewell for the night.

"No promises," Gabriel replied brightly as he started walking down the street with Sam in tow.

Gabriel took his keys out of his pocket, opening the door to the Novak house that still had its lights on, to Gabriel's surprise. He soon figured out why when he heard quiet singing coming from the kitchen, something that Lucifer does when he's happy, so it's rare but beautiful to hear.

Gabriel whistled, putting his keys down and locking the door after him and Sam entered. "What's got you so happy?" Gabriel asked loudly, making his way to the kitchen.

After seeing that Lucifer had a huge smile on his face while quietly singing for him. by Troye Sivan and making two cups of hot chocolate Sam smiled and beat Gabriel to the punch by saying, "Let me guess, is it Michael?"

Lucifer's face turned a bright red as he ducked his head, nodding slightly.

"Oh my gods, seriously?" Gabriel asked, happy to be fed gossip.

"Yes, you dumbass," Lucifer replied, no heat behind his words.

"Fucking finally," Sam mumbled.

"Well, you two have fun, I gotta get back to my boyfriend," Lucifer said, finishing up the hot chocolate. "My boyfriend," he repeated to himself, walking away singing for him. with a smile.

"Wow he's lovestruck," Gabriel commented, watching his older brother walk back to his room.

"Wouldn't be shocked if Michael was the same," Sam said.

"So... wanna go to my room and eat candy until 6 am?" Gabriel asked.

"Definitely."

And that night every Novak, Winchester or Milton went to bed thinking the same thing:

Best Halloween ever.

My headcanon is Kevin cusses like a sassy sailor and Lucifer is secretly an indie music junkie with a beautiful voice. Please vote and comment and thanks for reading!