Slenderman - "I like all of them. I like all of nature."
Sally - "Dogs! Especially corgis! They're so cute!"
Laughing Jack - "Rats. There were always a lot of them where I used to live. I always liked them."
Eyeless Jack - "Cats. I'm always bringing home stray cats and getting in trouble for it. I can't help it, they're just so cute."
Ben Drowned - "I like horses. They're fun to ride."
Jeff the Killer - "Dogs. Like Smile."
Nina the Killer - "Sheep. I like the way they sound."
Homicidal Liu - "Cats and dogs are both good."
Clockwork - "I like giraffes best. I used to have a stuffed giraffe when I was little, but it burned with the rest of my house. Maybe I should get a new one some time..."
Masky - "Bears. They're just awesome."
Hoodie - "I like guinea pigs."
Ticci Toby - "I - I like t-turtles!"
Kate the Chaser - "Cheetahs. They're really fast!"
Nurse Ann - "Snakes."
Judge Angels - "Birds! I like how they fly!"
Bloody Painter - "Fish are cool."
Puppeteer - "Bats. They're cool."
Zero - "Spiders and other bugs."
Kagekao - "Cats."
Suicide Sadie - "I like bunnies! They're super cute."