Slenderman - "Human children. Between the ages of 3 to 7 are my favourite. Oh, don't look like that! You already knew that's what I eat. This is why I don't eat in front of the others. Some of them also find it disturbing."
Sally - "Chocolate! Especially chocolate milk! But not regular milk though. That's yucky."
Laughing Jack - "Literally anything sweet. And any kind of candy."
Eyeless Jack - "I'll eat any human organ, but I love kidneys! Usually that's all I eat because they're just so good! Do you want to try one?"
Ben Drowned - "Tacos! They're the best food ever."
Jeff the Killer - "I love sour candy. But I can't eat it for a while after re-doing my smile or it burns really bad. Learned that the hard way.
Nina the Killer - "Chili. But not too spicy. I hate spicy food."
Homicidal Liu - "Pizza! But no pineapples. Gross. Yes pineapples! How do you not like them? We can never decide on how to eat it though..."
Clockwork - "Spaghetti. With meatballs. Oh, and garlic bread!"
Masky - "I do like cheesecake as a treat every now and then, but usually I actually tend to go for more healthy foods like salads. Gotta stay in shape to be a proxy!"
Hoodie - "I like s-sandwiches and strawberry ice cream!"
Ticci Toby - "W-Waffles! Did y-you really h-have to a-ask!?"
Kate the Chaser - "I like any kind of fruit."
Nurse Ann - "Fish."
Judge Angels - "I'll eat pretty much anything!"
Bloody Painter - "Cereal I guess."
Puppeteer - "French fries. But not if they're too salty. I hate salty food."
Zero - "I will eat anything if it's food."
Kagekao - "Does wine count?"
Suicide Sadie - "I like chicken."