This started as a joke but it's kinda fun now

First things first, the easiest choice for me.

Amy is Josh Hutcherson, period.  Moving on-

Next, Alister is Henry Emily!  Couldn't think of anything else so have a crappily drawn Alister in a vest and bow tie :')

*phone rings*

Hello?  Hello?  Uh, I wanted to record a message for you...

Here's our phone guy! 

...

...

FIVE NIGHTS, FIVE INNOCENT LIVES-

And finally. I had to keep the joke alive.

TĦÉ ĘŅBŶ BÊĦĮŃÐ TĦĚ ŞŁĄŰĞĦȚĖŘ