Let's see...

With the horses, I chose to take Petra cuz who does love Petra

In the cave the cave with Gabriel, I told him to stay put so he didn't kill himself

I took the cake...

I saved my potion of leaping until later in the episode

ILOVEPUZZLES

I used the leaping to get into the Witherstom

And...how am I supposed to know? I haven't played this game in months