UPSTAIRS

"I grew up in this town. I used to come up here as a little girl. The Wasserlaufs, Howard and Doreen – they used to own this farm back then.My co-worker, Jack, may he rest in peace, he worked here as a farmhand. Howard was a nice man, but... Well, he'd get into that corn liquor, and ... one night he got it into his thick skull that Jack and his wife, Doreen, were rolling around in the hay. It wasn't true, but – but Howard's paranoia got the better of him. He tried to kill them both. Jack got away, but Doreen..." Ruth Says

"He killed her?" Sam Says

"With a meat cleaver. Got life in jail. Which for Howard ended a year ago. He always swore he'd get his revenge on poor old Jack, and ... looks like he finally got it." Ruth Says

"Is Howard buried here in town?" Sam Asks
As Ruth looks at him

________________________________

CEMETERY

Sam and Dean are digging up Jack's grave.

"So ... Dad didn't want you to tell me. How come? Was this place really so bad?" Sam Says

"I don't really remember. I mean, look, nobody bad touched me. Nobody burned me with their smokes, or beat me with a metal hanger. I call that a win." Sam laughs a little, He hits something hard with his shovel. "Hey." Dean Says

Sam and Dean toss their shovels and opens up the coffin to reveal a corpse, They pour salt over it, and lighter fluid.

"All right. Let's barbecue old MacDonald here, get the hell out of Dodge." Dean Says As They toss a light, stand and watch

The Next Day Sam and Dean are back on the road driving.

SONNY'S HOUSE

"Ave Maria" is playing on an old-fashioned radio Inside in a bathroom. Ruth cross is draped on the sink as she is relaxing in the bath listening to the music. The lights start flickering but Ruth doesn't notice because she has a washcloth over her eyes. A frost forms on the mirror, and Ruth breath suddenly is visible, indicating a sudden chill. The shower curtain slides on its rings, and then falls over her face. She is struggling and screaming, trying to peel the shower curtain off her face.

"Help! Help!" Ruth Says As Sonny knocks on the bathroom door.

"Ruth, you okay? What's wrong?" Sonny Asks

Ruth being murdered in the bath, and Sonny banging on the door to get in, and the volume on the radio going up. The close-up of Ruth's face through the shower curtain is really grotesque. Her hand rigidly grasps the side of the bathtub, then relaxes ... with a splash into the bathtub.

"Open up! Ruth!" Sonny Says

CUS PLACE "HOME STYLE MEALS"

Dean and Sam are sitting at a table. Dean, with a sly smile on his face, is watching the waitress who is at the counter, laughing with some other customers.

"Dean, you know I'm fine just grabbing a burger-to-go somewhere, right?" Sam Says

"What, and miss out on the best banana pancakes you ever had?" Sam Says

FLASHBACK

Young Dean looks down at menu, He's sitting across from Sonny.

"Thanks." Dean Says

"No prob. I do this for all the boys after they've been here for a month." Sonny Says

"I meant for getting the charges against me dropped." Dean Says

"Well, being hungry's not a crime. It's the stealing that is. But I feel if you only do that once, you don't deserve a record. And seeing as how we can't find your pops anywhere, you can stay here as long as you want, Dean. You're doing good in school. You're making friends. You made the wrestling team. I'm proud of you...Let me ask you something, and I want you to be straight with me. Are you into the whole heavy-metal, devil-worshiping stuff?" Sonny Says

"What? No." Dean Says

"Hey, I'm not – I'm not judging. It's just I found a few occult-looking symbols carved into your bedpost." Sonny Says

"It's a very long story." Dean Says

"That story have anything to do with why you put the salt in front of your bunk door every night before bed?" Sonny Says

"Well, it's a family thing, so I can't really talk about it." Dean Says

"Same family that left you here?" Dean scoffs and looks down "What are you – what are you, in the mob or something?" Sonny Says

"More like something." Dean looks back down at his Menu

LI was part of this gang, right? They were my family. I lived, breathed, I would have even died for them. You know where it got me? 15 years in a correctional facility. And for what? Being loyal? To who? I should have been loyal to myself. Because you get one shot at this game, Dean, and when you look in the mirror, you want the guy looking back at you to be his own man." Sonny Says

Young Dean nods then a Young Waitress with the name Robin, she comes to their table.

"Hey, guys." Robin Says

"Hey, Robin. How are you?" Sonny Asks

"I'm good. How are you?" Robin Says

"Good. Meet my new ranch foreman here, Dean." Sonny Says As Dean eyes her name tag, Robin

PRESENT

"Hi. Welcome to Cus's. What can I get you two?" Robin Asks

"Bet you never thought you'd see me here, huh?" Dean Says Smiling

Robin looks at him with a blankly friendly expression. "Uh, look, I'm a little bit slammed right now. Do you guys want to hear the specials?"

"Robin ... Dean Winchester." He Says

"Um ..." Robin Says

"I used to live up at Sonny's." Dean Says
As Sam watches on with interest

"Oh, oh. Uh, look, sorry. There's just – there's so many boys that pass through there, it's – it's hard to remember every – every name and face." Robin Says

"Yeah. Uh, no. Sorry, I just – I remember you coming up there with your mom. She'd give guitar lessons. It's, uh – it was a long time ago." Dean Says

"Yeah. Mom – she loved helping out the boys. I guess that's why I kept giving lessons after she passed." Robin Says then clears her throat and there's an awkward silence

"Hey, Robin?"

"Um, would you excuse me? I'll be right back." Robin Says

"Dude ...?" Sam Says

"Let's go." Dean Says

He gets up quickly grabbing his jacket, Sam gets up and follows him. Seconds later they're outside walking to the Impala.

"Wh – what was that?" Sam Asks

"Nothing." Dean Says

"Nothing? Well, obviously it was something. Who was that waitress?" Sam Says

"I said it was nothing, all right? Drop it." His
phone is ringing; he picks it up. "Sonny..What?!" Dean Says

SONNY'S HOUSE

Outside a van slams shut and a Police car is behind it. Police radio is chattering. Dean, Sam, and Sonny look on.

"I tried to get in to save her, but the damn door wouldn't open." Sonny Says

"Locked?" Sam Says

"There's no locks on the farm." Sonny Says
As Dean sighs

"That means our little field trip to the cemetery was a bust. Sonny, is there anything else weird you can remember?" Dean Asks

"What, 'cause we're not chest-deep in weird already, boys?" Sam Says

"I know, I know. I mean anything – really." Dean Says

"There was one thing. Ruth always had her rosary beads with her, but now I can't find them anywhere." Sonny Says

"All right. Um, let's start with the vics, okay? I mean, both lived in the house. They both, uh, worked closely with the boys." Sam Says

"All right, why don't I go have a chat with the rug rats, see what's up?" Dean walks off

"Yeah. Sonny, you got any employee records on the victims?" Sam Asks

"In my office..Let's do it." Sonny Says

Dean is walking around the house and he hears some kids talking.

"Come on, whatcha gonna do about it? You gonna cry?"

"Timmy, you're such a little weirdo."

Dean picks up his pace to intervene, He grabs The first boy previously in the red sweatshirt kid and now in a camouflage pattern shirt and the other boy, previously in a plaid flannel shirt and now in a dark t-shirt, is pushing up against Timmy against the side of the house.

"Hey, hey, hey, hey! Hey! What are you doing? Come here. Huh?" Dean Says

"Nothing." He Says

"Timmy, what's going on?" Timmy stays silent "All right, you two. Where were you this morning when Ruth had her accident?" Dean Says

"Unless you're a cop, we don't need to tell you anything."

"Oh, okay. Well ..." He pulls an ID out of his pocket.
"... How about that?" Dean shoves an FBI badge in each of their faces

"We weren't even here this morning. Sonny sent us into town to get some chicken feed – we swear."

"What about Ruth? What can you tell me about her?" Dean Asks

"Uh, we used to call her the warden. She was a real Bible-thumping hard-ass."

"Obviously. What else? Anything different or weird you can think of?" Dean Asks

"You mean besides Timmy?" Both kids laugh and Timmy looks sad

"Hey! Either of you touch him ever again, I'm gonna go all Guantánamo on you. Understand me? You get the hell out of here. Go on! Get." Dean Says

Dean gestures irritably and the kids scurry off, He turns back toward Timmy who is watching the bigger kids go. Timmy steps forward to pick up his action figure and gives him a hand up.

"Hey. You and Bruce okay?" Dean Asks

"Yeah." Timmy Says

"Listen to me. Guys like that – they're cowards, okay? All you got to do is stand up to them one time and they'll stop, I promise." Dean Says

"Okay." Timmy Says

Inside Sam and Sonny are walking briskly through the house, Sam stops, seeing something.

"Hey Sonny, wait. Um ... W-what is all this?" Sam Asks

"It's our hall of fame we had some pretty great athletes come through here, including your brother. He was Sullivan county 135-pound wrestling champion." Sonny Says

Outside The House the two boys are doing yard work, They're being watched from above, from a window. Horn honks as a Car drives up, The Boys turn to see Robin getting out of car, with a guitar case.

"Hey, guys!" Robin Says

"She could give me a lesson anytime."

"Gross. She's like ancient."

He turns back to the lawnmower and It seems to pick up a rock, or something causing it to make a strange sound.

"What the hell?"

He then grabs the lever to turn it off. He tilts it on its side. We see that the underside has Ruth's cross caught up in the mechanism. And the other boy comes over to look.

"What's this doing in here?"

His Friend shrugs and shakes his head and He reaches his hand in cautiously and starts pulling out grass, and trying to pull off the cross necklace.
The view from the window above has ghostly noises, Timmy is standing in the window clutching his action figure. Below, The Kid is still working with the lawnmower.

The camera pauses on the red power lever for a moment. The Redhead boy watches to see what happens. Then the red power level switch flips and the engine turns over.

The Brown haired boy screams as blood sprays out over the redhead, Who tries to help his friend and he falls over as the lawnmower continues to run.
Timmy who's upstairs in then a hand clasps him on the shoulder a hand with what appears to be strange markings, tattoos or scarring.

_________________________________

SONNY'S OFFICE

Sam who's sitting at Sonny's desk is reviewing a file about Timmy, Then Dean walks in.

"Kid's gonna need about 8,000 stitches, but he'll be fine." Dean Says

"That kid was bullying Timmy before the accident, right?" Sam Asks

"Yeah. Why?" Dean Says

"Check this out." He hands Dean the file "Timmy was found in an abandoned building about a year ago all by himself. No one was sure how long he had been there." Sam Says

"And what about his parents?" Dean tosses file back to Sam

"Well, they posted a picture on the Internet, but no one ever showed up." Sam Says

"Well, then, what's he doing here? Shouldn't he be in an orphanage?" Dean Says

"He kept running away from Child Services. So about three months ago, Sonny offered to take him in." Sam Says

"All right, so hard-ass counselors, bullies, all bite the dust, but Timmy's still standing. So, what are we talking? We got ourselves a Damien on our hands?" Dean Says

"No. EMF rules out a demon. So ... probably ghost possession." Sam Says

"Meaning what, we find Timmy and shove a fistful of salt down his throat, forced ejection?..You're taking the barn this time." Dean turns around and heads out and Sam sighs, taps the folder

THE BARN

There's Chains rattling as Sam walks into the barn, He opens the same door where Dean found Timmy. Pigeons coo and Cows Moo in the background, Sam looks up, sees the rafters, a trapdoor which goes up a ladder. Upstairs, he looks around and pulls out a flashlight. Sees a child's drawing on a wall. The drawing shows a happy family. Then shows a car driving, with "YMMOM" which is Mommy spelled backwards then shows a car crash with flames and a Mom putting Timmy outside the car.

SONNY'S HOUSE

Dean is walking around, hears guitar; walks to room and sees Robin on the couch, playing guitar.

FLASHBACK

Young Robin is playing the guitar and Young Dean is sitting beside her. She plays a few chords and they laugh.

"So, you've been a lot of places." Robin Says

"Yeah. My, uh ... My dad likes to move around a lot." Dean Says

"What's your dad do?" Robin Asks

"Boring stuff." Dean Says

"Do you like it?" Robin Asks

Dean shakes his head "No, not really. But my dad expects me to follow in his footsteps. So I've kind of gotten used to it."

"Yeah. I - I get it. My pops wants me to take over the diner? But that's not happening. So, what do you really want to do?..I want to be a photographer and see the world, go to strange lands, eat crazy food." Robin Says

"I want to be a rock star, but... I also really like cars." Dean Says

"Being a mechanic seems rough." Robin Says

"What? No, no. Not at all. Cars are freaking cool as hell. Fixing them is like ... a puzzle, and the best part is when you're done, they leave, and you're not responsible for them anymore." Dean Says

Robin leans in to kiss him and Dean seems shocked.

"Have you kissed many girls?" Robin Asks

"What? Yeah. Of course. Lots." Dean Says

"Really?" She grabs his collar "Well, I guess we'll just have to keep practicing." Robin Says As She pulls him in for another kiss.