Five-Y/n's a Steal for Five and Seven

Dedicated to:Noneofurbeezwax24 I really think that you needed this.<3

(Vanya's power is not hidden)

(They're 14 in here,you are too ofc)

~Where Five and Vanya tries to make Y/n theirs

Third Person's P.O.V.:

Having a crush as a kid is normal,but fighting for a girl's heart without her even knowing because she's too oblivious is not normal at all,right?,well when did the Hargreeves siblings became normal?,Never.

"So how's the most prettiest girl in the academy doing?,"Y/n asked her bestfriend Vanya as she sat beside her

"I don't know,how are you doing?"Y/n blushed at what Vanya said

"I'm not pretty,"Y/n muttered

"Yes you ar—"but Vanya was cut off when Five appeared in front of them and sat beside Y/n on the sofa.

"You look beautiful today Y/n,not like its new since you always is"he said before taking a sip of coffee

Vanya glared at Five,but composed herself.

"I don't even know why can't they just confess already,"Allison whispered to Klaus as they watched Y/n be oblivious like always

"Oh shush Allison I just want to see what happens"Klaus smiled watching intently while Ben just reads a book beside them

"I think Y/n likes Five,"Diego commented

"No I think she likes Vanya,"Ben chimed

"I don't even know,I just want the trouble,"Klaus said

"Would you like to listen to me playing violin?,"Vanya asked Y/n

Y/n then slammed her book shut looking at Vanya before nodding excitedly.

Vanya smirked as its Five's turn to glare at her.

"How about you eat peanut butter sandwhiches with me instead?,"Five asked smiling at Y/n

"No,she agreed at me first!"Vanya yelled

"Well she can change her mind Vanya,"Five hissed

"How about—we do both?,at the same time.Okay?"Y/n asked smiling at them and they immediately melts at her smile so they agreed.

Y/n made the sandwich with Five before making him sit down beside her and listen to Vanya play her violin while their siblings sat in the sofa near them.

"You know this is better than tv dramas,"Klaus spoke

"Bet on you Five will snap in a few days now,"Luther chimed

"Yeah,they've been like this for weeks!"Allison added

"I still think she likes Five,"Diego commented

"Well I think,she likes Vanya,"Ben spoke up slamming his book shut

"Wanna bet?,"Klaus asked and they agreed

Luther,Allison and Diego thinks that Y/n likes Five while Ben and Klaus thinks Y/n likes Vanya.The loser will need to pay the winners 5 dollars each.

The Hargreeves' siblings gathered in the attic to watch some movies in a projector Y/n bought for them to secretly watch every weekend without Sir.Reginald knowing.

"Its so cold,"Y/n shivers rubbing her hands together for heat

"You can share with me!"Vanya and Five spoke in unison before glaring at eachother

"Here Y/n/n,"Klaus gave her an extra blanket and Y/n thanked him

Vanya and Five frowned missing the chances to cuddle with Y/n so they then glared at Klaus who smiled sheepishly at them and gave them a peace sign.

"Goodnight Five,"Y/n kissed Five's forehead making him blush

Y/n then faced Vanya and Vanya smiled closing her eyes waiting for a kiss on the forehead but Y/n just wrapped her arms on Vanya's shoulder smiling.

Vanya frowned but hugged Y/n back anyway.

Five laughed at Vanya's disappointment but Vanya glared at him.

"Goodnight Vanya,"

"Goodnight Y/n,"Vanya smiled at Y/n

Vanya,Y/n and Five went inside their rooms while the rest of their siblings said that they'll stay for a few more minutes.

As soon as they knew that they were out of ear shot,they scramble near eachother looking at one another.

"I think that's one point for Five,"Diego said

"No!,definitely for Vanya,"Klaus commented

"She kissed Five!,—kissed!"Luther explained

"In the forehead!"Klaus reasoned

"And the hug is longer than the kiss,"Ben added

"Well the kiss is more meaningful than the hug,"Allison chimed in

"Na uh—maybe she kissed him as a friend!"Klaus smirked

"Maybe she hugged Vanya as a friend!"Allison smirked crossing her arms

"Goodmorning Y/n!,"Five and Vanya scooted and motioned for Y/n to sat beside them

Instead on choosing on either side,she sat in the middle of them to be fair.

"Do you want to do anything today Y/n?,"Five asked

But before Y/n could answer,Vanya cut her off

"Yeah,she's hanging out with me"Vanya chimed in

"She hanged out with you yesterday!"Five yelled

"Well she can hang out with me again!"Vanya yelled back

Y/n glanced back and forth at the two feeling exhausted.

'Can't they just hang out with me at the same time?'she thought

"Guys—"

"No its my turn!"Five yelled louder standing

"No we already talked about hanging out today yesterday!"Vanya yelled louder standing in front of Five

They did this for a few more minutes until Y/n had enough,she stands up furious,she made a force field between them and the two finally shuts up looking at her.

"Y/n—"they started but Y/n is hella pissed

"Enough!,you two have been like this for almost a month and I'm so exhausted!"she yelled

Vanya and Five looked down feeling guilty.

"You think I haven't noticed your bickering and rivalry?,"Y/n asked but they didn't answer

Their hearts started beating fast and their breaths hitched.Did she know about their feelings for her?,are they making it hard for her to choose?.

"Like what's the problem?,"

Vanya and Five sighed in relief knowing she's still oblivious about their feelings.

While the rest of their siblings groaned internally from where they are watching.

"Arghhh,someone should tell her,"Allison sighed

"I'm gonna tell her,"Luther mumbled

"Don't you dare,"Diego glared at Luther

"Does this mean no points to either?,"Klaus asked

And Ben nodded,"Obviously"

"So none of you will speak?,"Y/n asked

Five opens his mouth to speak when Y/n cut him off,"I will not tolerate this kind of behavior anymore."

"I need you to be friends and shake your hands,"Y/n suggested now calming down.

Their head shot up looking Y/n.

Five shook his head,"No way,"he laughed breathly

"Yeah no way!"Vanya chimed in agreeing with Five

"See!,you two agreed at the same thing!That's a first,that means its possible being friends,"Y/n smiled

The two is persistent and just crossed their arms looking away from eachother.

But Y/n is more persistent.

"Fine!,I don't want to be friends with you two anymore!"Y/n yelled before walking away

Five and Vanya then looked up worried before looking at eachother then at Y/n.

"Y/n wait—,we're friends!"Five yelled shaking Vanya's hand

"Yes we are!See?,"Vanya shaked Five's hand

Y/n looks back to look at them and smiled when she saw them shaking hands.

She smiled walking up to them and hugged them at the same time.

"See?,now lets have afternoon coffee and sandwiches"Y/n pulled the two of them at the kitchen where Grace is.

Starting that day,Vanya and Five just takes care of Y/n and let her choose between them instead of tugging her back and forth.

Well it will surely take a very longgg time for Y/n to choose,since she doesn't even know that she was given options!.

But for now she knows that she loves both of them equally.

(That is where it ends but I decided to add an extra)
(Two Endings)

Extra:

Five Ending:

"That's the end of the book,"Y/n slammed shut the book that was written by Vanya which her and Five found in the rubles of the destroyed library.

"She's a good writer,she even wrote your rivalry,why do you even hate eachother?,"Y/n asked brushing Five's hair as he lay his head on her lap

"Believe it or not we're fighting for you,"Five sat up

"For me?,"Y/n asked in confusion

"Yeah,you're so oblivious that we're fighting to get your attention not because we hate eachother,"Five laughed reminiscing

"Awww,I'm so oblivious..."Y/n muttered under her breath frustratedly

"Yes you are,"Five laughs hugging Y/n as they rock back and forth under their make shift hut

"Well I hope I can see her again,"Y/n hugged Five back.

"Someday Y/n..."he whispered

"Someday."

Vanya Ending:

Y/n clapped her hands and screamed Vanya's name as she finished her performance.

Vanya waved at everyone and sent Y/n a flying kiss when she saw her in the crowd—which the girl caught.

After her performance,Y/n and Vanya went straight at the academy for their reunion that was set up by Ben.

(Yes he's alive here.)

They entered the house holding eachothers hand,laughing at a story Y/n was telling.

"Is the bet we made as a child still up or nah?,'cause I really need that Five dollars."Klaus whispered at Diego.

"Shut up Klaus."

Which ending did you choose or like best?

VOTE AND COMMENT BECAUSE I LOVE READING WHAT YOU GUYS THINK.

Comment or Message me for Request.